At Briarwood, Edward had also been reconsidering the past. He wrote to Elizabeth, acknowledging that his fear of repeating the family’s old mistakes had nearly prevented him from speaking honestly to Charlotte. His sister replied that offering a woman a choice was not the same as making one for her, and suggested that a gentleman who owned several thousand books ought occasionally to profit from reading them. Edward laughed aloud, then placed her letter beside his writing desk.

He did not hurry to Ashford Hall with flowers or a ring. Charlotte had asked for time, and he respected the request. Though their occasional meetings at village gatherings remained the brightest moments of his summer, they exchanged books, discussed the harvest, and spoke with an ease that no longer required them to pretend indifference.

Charlotte discovered that independence didn’t make her any less capable of affection. In fact, the more confidently she managed her own affairs, the more she understood what she wanted to share with someone else. The realization came on an ordinary morning while she was sketching an apple tree.

She found herself imagining Edward’s opinion of its crooked branches and smiled at the thought that she had begun measuring ordinary pleasures by whether she might someday enjoy them with him. For months she had fought for the right to refuse a marriage. Now she was free to choose one.

The following afternoon, she arrived at Briarwood without announcing her visit. The butler directed her to the library where Edward sat in the same enormous green armchair reading a newspaper under the pale September sunlight. Charlotte paused at the doorway, remembering the frightened woman who had hidden there in spring. That woman had believed her future belonged to everyone but herself.

She crossed the room without hesitation and Edward lowered his newspaper, visibly delighted, and rose to greet her, but Charlotte asked him to remain seated for a moment. She wished, she explained, to ask him a question that she had considered with unusual care. He folded the paper and gave her his full attention. Charlotte told him she intended to continue helping her father, drawing imperfect landscapes, reading whatever pleased her and occasionally disagreeing with the gentleman she married.

She had no desire to become an ornamental duchess whose opinions were valued only when they caused no inconvenience. Edward’s smile deepened as he assured her that he would find such a woman dreadfully dull. Encouraged by the warmth in his eyes, Charlotte placed one hand upon the back of the chair.

“Your Grace, would you consider marrying a woman who once hid behind your furniture?”

For once Edward Hawthorn seemed entirely incapable of producing a suitable reply. He stared at her, then slowly removed his spectacles, as though clearer sight might help him believe what he was seeing. When he finally asked whether she was proposing to him, Charlotte admitted that she was, adding that she hoped his silence did not indicate a refusal. Edward reached for her hand.