“And look here,” said Mrs. Dunning pointing a stubby finger at the stamp on the canvas. “That’s the mark of Holloway’s Mill at Ashby. We don’t buy from Holloway’s, never have. Our flour comes from the mill at Wexley Bridge. So, these sacks were never ours to begin with.”

Rose looked up at the solicitor.

“30 sacks claimed as spoiled. 30 replacement sacks bought from Pell at £1 10 shillings each. £45 for flour we never lost.”

Mr. Fenwick wrote it down. The Duke looked at his cook.

“Mrs. Dunning, you walked 6 miles into town with a sack of sawdust on your back.”

“I came in on the carrier’s cart, Your Grace. I’m not a fool. But I’d have walked it.”

Then she reached out and squeezed Rose’s good wrist.

“You were right about the eggs, too,” she muttered. “Last year, I never said so. I’m saying so now.”

“Thank you, Mrs. Dunning.”

“Don’t thank me. Just come home when this is done. The new girl they’ve sent me can’t count past 12.”

That evening, Rose stayed late in the chambers to copy the flour figures by lamplight, and the Duke waited by the cold fireplace to see her safely back to the Bell.

“May I ask you something?” he said at last.

“You may ask.”

“Why did you start the Backgate book 2 years ago? Nobody asked you to.”

Rose set down her pen.

“Because of the roofs,” she said. “My first winter here, I found Mrs. Abney at the North Cottages with a baby and a roof that had leaked for 3 years. Mr. Garrow kept telling her the repairs were on order. I could not prove it was anything but carelessness. So, I started counting what came through the gate. If you count everything, the truth eventually stands up by itself.”

He was quiet for a long time.

“My father,” he said slowly, “trusted Garrow completely. He used to say that a good steward was worth more than a good horse, and that a gentleman should never be seen checking his own servants’ sums. He never once went out to the cottages himself. Garrow told him everything was well, and he believed it.”

“And you?”

“I went out the winter after he died. I found a little girl at the Hobbs cottage with a fever, lying in a bed under a hole in the roof. The rain came straight down on her blanket. She lived. Thank God, she lived.”

He looked at his own hands.

“And I asked Garrow why, and Garrow said my father had approved a delay, and I believed him because it was easier than believing my father had been a fool.”

“Your father was not a fool. He was trusting.”

“There is not as much difference as I would like. Everyone tells a duke what he wants to hear. In 3 years, you were the only person in that house who ever told me something I did not want to hear. Most people find that a disagreeable habit in a servant. I found it the most valuable thing I owned.”

He paused.

“That is a poor way to put it. You were never a thing I owned.”

“No,” she said gently. “I was not.”

“Rose,” he said.

It was the first time he had ever used her Christian name. It hung in the air between them, and neither of them pretended not to hear it.

“Thomas,” she answered very quietly. “Since we are being improper.”

He took one step toward her, then another. She stood up from the table. They were close enough now that she could see the lamplight in his eyes. And then he stopped.

He stood very still. She watched him decide something. She watched it cost him.

“You are on my payroll,” he said quietly. “Through Fenwick, but on my payroll all the same. I will not take a single step more while you depend on my money for your bread. When this is finished and you owe me nothing, I would like to ask you a question. Not before.”

Rose swallowed.

“That,” she said unsteadily, “is the most ungentlemanly thing a gentleman has ever said to me. And the most honorable.”

“Then I have managed both at once. I shall write it in the ledger.”