It took him another week to construct the words properly. When he arrived at the estate unannounced, Catherine was in the library cataloging the new acquisition with such concentration that she didn’t immediately notice him. He stood for a moment watching her work, the precise notation in her margins, the care with which she handled each volume, the absolute absorption in a task that was genuinely hers.
“You’re arguing from habit,” he said, repeating her own words back to her, “not from conviction. You’re convinced you can be happy on your own, so you’re arguing as though you want to be. But what if you could be happy with someone who doesn’t diminish that independence? What if the argument was simply, ‘I’m happy with my life. Would you like to be happy with your life and also with me?'”
Catherine set down her pen very slowly.
“That’s not a proposal. That’s a philosophical question.”
“Yes,” the Duke said. “I’m aware that you require actual philosophical coherence. So, here it is. You are the rudest woman I have ever met and the most interesting person I have ever encountered. I don’t want to marry you because I need to marry someone respectable. I want to marry you because you’ve made everything else in my life seem like background noise. That is selfish and impractical and entirely contrary to everything sensible, and I’m hoping you’ll be selfish and impractical enough to agree.”
Catherine stood, walking closer but not close enough to touch.
“You’re going to have to ask me properly with a ring, with witnesses, with all of the proper tedious ritual that you’ve spent five years avoiding.”
“Is that a yes?” the Duke asked.
“It’s a request for proposal protocol,” Catherine said. “I’ve compromised enough about propriety. I see no reason to compromise on this.”
He left the library, returned to London, acquired a ring that had belonged to his grandmother, a woman who had apparently been rather formidable in her own right, and returned with the entire Marquess household as witnesses. The actual proposal occurred in the library standing between stacks of books with Catherine looking simultaneously exasperated and precisely as satisfied as the Duke had ever seen her.
“I still think needlework is a waste of time,” she said after she had agreed.
“I know,” he said. “I’m rather counting on that.”
The wedding took place four months later at the cathedral in the county town with Mrs. Pembroke presiding with the satisfaction of a woman whose schemes had precisely the outcome she’d intended. The Duke’s family was initially scandalized by the choice of a companion with no family connection, and then impressed by Catherine’s published paper on agricultural reform, and finally charmed by her tendency to introduce political philosophy into conversation with precisely the people who had expected her to politely discuss needlework and the color blue.
