The second was that Lady Genevieve Carstairs discovered that the engagement was a lie. She discovered it because she was clever and patient and had been watching. And because she had at last got a servant of the Berkeley Square house to talk. The servant had overheard weeks before a conversation in the library between the Duke and Miss Whitgrove, in which the words fiction and release and when the season is over had figured plainly. It was enough.

Lady Genevieve did not need proof that would stand in a court. She needed only enough truth to make a story and she had it. And she chose her moment with the care of a woman who has waited a whole season to be revenged. And her moment was the Duke’s own ball.

Hesper found her chance to speak to the Duke on the afternoon before it. She had meant to release him gently in private before the ball. She owed him that, she thought, before the whole world gathered to celebrate a thing that was not real. She found him in the library and she had her whole speech prepared. And she got perhaps four sentences into it before it all went wrong.

“Your Grace,” she began, because she had gone back deliberately to the formal address as a way of putting the necessary distance between them. “The season is nearly over. You have had your peace and I am glad of it. And I think the time has come to speak of ending our arrangement as we agreed before the ball makes it harder to end. I do not want you to feel bound by a promise made in a crisis. I release you from it. Whatever is said afterward, whatever the gossip, I will bear it. I have borne worse and I would rather bear it than hold you to a fiction a moment longer than honor requires. You have been more than fair to me. I only wish to be fair to you in return.”

She had rehearsed it a hundred times and she got through it steadily. And it was, she thought, rather well done, dignified and clear, and giving nothing of herself away. And she looked up when it was finished, expecting relief in his face, and found instead something she had not prepared for at all. He looked as though she had struck him.

“You wish to end it,” he said.

“I wish to free you from it,” said Hesper. “There is a difference. It was never a thing you chose. You reached for the nearest hand in a burning room. I have been glad to be that hand. But a man should not have to marry the hand he reached for. And I will not let this arrangement become the very trap you were trying to escape. That is all. It is the only honorable thing, and we both know it.”

And the Duke of Kelvinridge, who had spent three days composing the words with which he would ask her to stay, found that every one of them had deserted him. The woman he loved was standing in his library releasing him from the only good thing that had happened to him in two years. She was doing it out of honor, out of a scrupulous care for his freedom, out of the plain unselfish decency that was the very reason he loved her. And he could not find, in the wreck of his prepared speech, a single word to tell her so.

So, he said the wrong thing. He said, stiffly, coldly, because coldness was the armor he reached for when he was hurt past bearing, that if that was her wish, he would not stand in the way of it, and that they would speak of the particulars after the ball. And he turned away to the window. And the moment broke.

Hesper, who had come to free him, and had somehow contrived to feel as though she had been dismissed, gathered the pieces of her dignity, and left the library. And neither of them had said the one true thing that would have mended it. Because both of them were too proud and too frightened and too certain of being unwanted to risk it.