The Duke lifted his head. Dr. Fenwick turned sharply.

“That is no one,” the doctor said quickly. “A pauper patient. Come, Your Grace, I’ll take you back inside. It’s very cold.”

But Nell was already half running across the muddy yard, and a large matron in a white cap stepped forward to block her.

“Here, you can’t go there, miss.”

“Let her pass,” said the Duke of Ravensworth in a voice that could have cut through stone.

The matron stepped back.

Nell came to the fourth woman in the line and stopped in front of her. The woman flinched away, the way an animal flinches that has been struck many times. She would not lift her eyes. Very slowly, Nell knelt down in the mud.

“Ma’am,” she said softly. “I’m not going to hurt you. I’m a bootmaker. Those boots don’t fit you at all, do they? I can see they hurt. May I look at your feet, only for a moment?”

The woman said nothing, but she did not pull away. Gently, Nell unlaced the heavy left boot. It was stuffed with rags at the toe, folded with great care, the way a person folds them when they have spent years trying to make a cruel thing bearable. Beneath a darned gray stocking was a foot.

A narrow foot with a very high, delicate instep. And a smallest toe that turned inward, crooked where an old break had been poorly set long ago after a little girl jumped from a hayloft because her big brother dared her to. Nell’s eyes filled with tears.

“Lady Clara,” she whispered.

The woman went perfectly still. Then, slowly, as though it cost her enormous effort, she lifted her head. Her eyes were a pale, startling blue, exactly the same blue as the duke’s.

“Who are you?” she said.

Her voice was hoarse, as though she had not used it in a long while.

“How do you know that name? No one here knows that name. They said if I said it again, they would put me back in the dark room.”

“My name is Nell Hartley,” said Nell, and her voice broke. “I’m Thomas Hartley’s daughter.”

The woman stared at her. Her lips moved.

“Mr. Hartley,” she whispered. “Mr. Hartley, did he… Did he keep my letter? Did he give it to Alex?”

And from behind Nell came a sound, a voice that was barely a voice at all.

“Clara.”

The woman’s eyes moved past Nell, past the matron, past the line of frightened gray women to the tall, dark-haired man standing in the mud of the yard with tears running down his face. For a long moment, she simply looked at him. As though she had dreamed this moment so many thousands of times that she could no longer tell the dream from the waking.

“Alex,” she said.

“I came.”

He was walking toward her, stumbling.

“I came, Clara. I’m so sorry. I’m so sorry it took so long. I came.”

“I knew you would,” said Lady Clara Thorne. “I told them every day for 8 years. I told them my brother would come for me.”

And then he had her in his arms, his thin, gray, broken little sister, and he was holding her as though he would never in his life let her go. And she was sobbing against his chest like a child, and the whole cold yard of Salt Moor House had gone absolutely silent, except for the wind and the sea and the sound of a duke weeping. Nell knelt in the mud with Clara’s boot in her hands and cried, too. And somewhere behind her, Mrs. Dobbs was crying loudest of all.

Dr. Fenwick tried to slip away through the gate, but the duke’s coachman caught him before he reached the road. By nightfall, the magistrate of Whitby had been summoned, and the doctor, pale and sweating, was confessing everything. The drugged young woman brought before dawn in April 1811, the tall, pale agent who called himself Mr. Smith and signed every quarterly letter since with the initials SC, £40 a quarter for 8 years, and strict instructions. No letters, no visitors, and no name but Mrs. Grey.

“Mr. Crane wrote 2 years ago that the duke had begun asking questions again,” Fenwick whimpered. “If anyone came looking, I was to say she had died. I bought the stone myself. There is no one under it at all.”