She had taken temporary work keeping accounts for a charity school. She liked the people, but the pay was lower and the journey longer.

“What do you want from him?”

“A fair account of why I left. I want those whose signatures appear on those papers to understand how they were used.”

Her answer reminded me that the undertaking’s crisis reached beyond the affair. Clerks and laborers had paid for decisions they never made. Subscribers had relied on claims they did not know were disputed. Families had ordered their lives around employment that might disappear.

I returned to my difficulties with a different sense of scale. Richard had humiliated me. I was not required to solve the damage he had done everywhere else. I could give evidence about his visit and be honest about what I did not know. I could end my marriage without pretending to know how the financial inquiries would conclude.

I could support Caroline’s right to be heard without becoming responsible for proving every allegation. That distinction between accountability and revenge was the first thing that allowed me to sleep through the night.

CHAPTER THIRTEEN: OLIVIA’S QUESTION

Olivia Lawson came to see me on a Sunday afternoon, accompanied by an older cousin who waited in the front room. I had met her only once, at a winter assembly. She introduced herself carefully and asked whether I could spare a few minutes. We sat on the back steps overlooking the little garden, where the open door left us within sight of her companion.

“I know this is strange. I shall not be offended if you refuse.”

“What do you need to know?”

“Did my father really come here and ask you to discredit my mother?”

I felt uneasy discussing a father with his daughter. I explained that I had made a written account of the conversation, that Nora had heard it, and that both statements were with my solicitor.

“I shall not give you something merely to make you hate him. I shall not tell you it did not happen either.”

Her breathing changed.

“He told me you threatened him.”

“I did not.”

“He says you and my mother are working together to disgrace him because of the affair.”

I looked at the cracked brick beside the step.

“Your mother approached me because she feared what was happening with the subscription’s papers. We are not pursuing a personal attachment.”

Olivia looked embarrassed.

“I am sorry I asked.”

“You are allowed to ask questions about your own life.”

She was quiet for a moment.

“Mama says she does not want me to choose sides. It makes everything harder, because Papa tells me every day she is turning me against him.”

I chose my words carefully.

“You may care about both parents and still decide whether their explanations make sense.”

She began to cry. I waited while she collected herself.

“I wish they had settled this without involving me.”

“So do I.”

After she left, I sent Caroline a short note explaining that Olivia had visited and that I had disclosed no confidential papers. Caroline thanked me. She added that Olivia had agreed to stay with her the following weekend. I put the answer away and remained outside until dusk.

For the first time, I considered the years ahead without trying to picture Richard’s defeat. I imagined a house where nobody was forced to choose a story before understanding it.

PART 10

CHAPTER FOURTEEN: THE EXAMINATION

Paul prepared me for a formal examination concerning Richard’s visit. He reminded me that my direct knowledge was narrow. I knew Richard had appeared at my house. I knew what he offered and what he requested in return. I did not know the full contents of the subscription’s books or every reason the trustees had required him to withdraw.

During the examination, I described the conversation without ornament. Asked whether Richard threatened me, I repeated his words rather than interpreting his intentions. Asked whether he offered to influence Jessica’s position in our separation, I answered yes. Asked what I understood the offer to mean, I explained that he wanted me to undermine Caroline’s credibility.

I supplied my written account through counsel. Nora had provided hers separately. One of those hearing the evidence asked whether she had been present throughout the conversation.