Lord Fenn rose as he always rose to speak last and to warm applause. The applause was uncertain this year.

“Before Lord Fenn begins,” said Arthur, rising instead, “the Duchess of Lorne and I would like to say a few words about how reputations are built and what they are sometimes built on.”

Fenn’s expression went very still.

“48 days ago,” Arthur said. “Lord Fenn shoved my wife against a wall in her own house, called her stupid, and told her to find a mop. He left before he learned who she was. He held his head high on the way out.”

He paused.

“He has been holding his head high for a considerable time. I should like this room to hear what that looks like from the ground.”

Vivian stood. She nodded once toward the door. Mrs. Sutton came in from the anteroom. She had traveled from Brampton that morning in a carriage Vivian had arranged. She stood near the door and did not look at Fenn.

“My name is Margaret Sutton,” she said.

Her voice shook and then steadied.

“I was housekeeper at Lord Fenn’s Hertfordshire property for 6 years. He struck me in the linen room for a wine error I made at his supper table. He dismissed me without a character. I spent 4 months on £30 looking for another position before I found one.”

She sat down.

Miss Carey stood next. She had come from St. Albans. She stated her name, her former position, and a single incident briefly and clearly.

When she sat, she did not look away from the front of the room. She had decided something, Vivian thought, on the drive from St. Albans. She had decided she was done being the only one keeping the secret.

Thomas Price’s account was read aloud by Arthur, since Price had not been able to leave Cambridgeshire. It was two pages. It took 4 minutes. George Fielder, who had made it to Ware in person, stood last.

“I have read the accounts Mr. Holt just presented,” he said.

He was not a man accustomed to speaking in assembly rooms, but he was a man accustomed to keeping his head level on difficult ground.

“Lord Fenn published £300 more than he gave this society last year. I know because I was on the project that money was meant for. I watched it not arrive, and I did not say anything because I did not think I would be believed.”

He paused.

“I find I am willing to say it now.”

Four voices, four separate counties. Four people who until Vivian had gone looking had never compared their accounts because it had never occurred to any of them that there was someone to compare with.

Lord Fenn rose to speak. His composure had developed cracks. They showed at the edges now, around the eyes, in the set of his jaw.

“These are disgruntled former servants,” he said. “People let go for cause who have conveniently discovered a grievance the moment a duchess arrives with the means to encourage one. I have given this society nine years of my time and my resources, gentlemen. Nine years against the word of a laundress and two dismissed domestics and a groundskeeper with a grudge.”

“And against your own accounts,” said Mr. Holt quietly.

He had a ledger open in front of him. He did not look up from it.

“My lord.”

The room was very still.

“Explain to us,” said Arthur in the same level voice he had used in the Hartwell House corridor, “how four people in four separate counties who have never met one another arrive at an identical account of the same man without coaching, without comparison, using their own words?”