“Lydia, listen to yourself,” Verity said firmly. “I went out because the missing hatboxes had arrived and you wished to have them before the ball. I was carrying three of your bandboxes and two spools of ribbon back to the house, and I meant to put them away and spend the evening upstairs. I did not know the Duke was waiting beside the garden path. He had remembered something I said when we arrived, while you were thanking him for the invitation. I hid nothing from you then, and I am hiding nothing from you now.”

“You knew what this visit meant to me,” Lydia cried, her hands clenching at her sides as a tear spilled over her lashes. “You knew Aunt Ruth told everyone in the village that the Duke of Witchmere had invited us for 10 days, and you let me sit at the pianoforte and wear my best lace while you went out into the garden with him every morning. If you cared for me as you always professed to do, you would have told him on the very first day that you had no wish to put yourself forward in my place.”

Verity looked at her younger sister, seeing both the real sting of disappointed vanity and the long habit of 4 years in which every small luxury, every new bonnet, and every promising acquaintance in their family had been automatically handed to Lydia first. For a moment, Verity felt a deep pang of sorrow that their closeness had been built on so unequal a foundation, where peace existed only so long as Verity wanted nothing for herself.

“I have helped you gladly for 4 years, Lydia,” Verity said quietly, though every word carried unmistakable weight. “I have mended your lace, packed your trunks, and stayed by the wall so you could have the extra ticket to the assembly. I do not begrudge a single hour of it. Yet, His Grace never courted you, never promised you his attention, and never looked at you as anything more than a guest in his house. If I refuse to speak with him now, it would not make him turn to you tomorrow. It would only throw away a regard that I value deeply in order to preserve a daydream that was never real.”

Lydia pressed the back of her hand against her mouth, her chest heaving with a mixture of anger and mortification.

“I do not want your lectures, Verity, and I certainly do not want your help with my gowns tonight. You may go to your own room and draw as many hedges as you please, for I would rather pin my own hair crookedly than have you stand behind my chair while everyone in the drawing room whispers about us.”

Verity bent down, picked up the fallen turquoise necklace from the carpet, and laid it gently upon the edge of the dressing table without touching the dresses on the bed.

“I did not come to lecture you, Lydia. I came so that you would hear the truth from your sister before you heard a single rumor from a stranger. I shall leave you to dress in peace.”

When the family met in the drawing room before dinner that evening, the change was quiet, but unmistakable to anyone who knew them. Lydia entered with Aunt Ruth, her curls pinned slightly lower than usual, and her chin held stiffly high. And instead of looking toward the door for the Duke, she seated herself immediately beside the young Shropshire squire who had admired her at the ball. Aunt Ruth looked nervously from one niece to the other, tapping her fan against her wrist.