“Your Grace,” Lydia said, stepping half a pace into the aisle between the chairs as Hugh picked up the book. “Mr. Aubrey and I were just disputing whether the view from the west tower is finer at sunset or in the morning. You promised on the first night of our arrival that we should see all the beauties of Witchmere before we left, and I have not yet been up the tower stairs at all.”

“It is a very clear climb today, Miss Lydia,” Hugh replied, stopping with perfect politeness and smiling at both her and the young squire. “The housekeeper leaves the west tower key on the brass hook beside the vestry door whenever the weather is dry. Mr. Aubrey knows the stair well, for he climbed it with my cousins last spring, and if Mrs. Bellamy cares to walk as far as the courtyard bench, you will have a view all the way to the Malvern Hills before luncheon.”

He bowed to them both with the pleasant, unhurried friendliness of an older brother or a benevolent landlord, and then walked out into the hall where Lydia could see through the open doorway that Verity was waiting for him with her green spencer buttoned and her leather sketchbook under her arm. Hugh did not merely bow to Verity. As soon as he reached her, he took the heavy wooden ruler she was carrying so she could pull on her gloves and said something in a low voice that made her laugh before they walked out toward the terrace together. Lydia stood still by the window with the cherry ribbon hanging from her fingers, watching the two of them cross the hall side by side. She felt the last fragment of her illusion drop away. There had been no secret artifice on Verity’s part and no misunderstanding on the duke’s.

He had never looked at Lydia the way he looked at Verity when she was merely pulling on a pair of plain leather gloves. He had been courteous to Lydia because she was Verity’s sister and a guest under his roof, nothing more. When Mr. Aubrey cleared his throat and asked diffidently whether she still wished to fetch the key from the vestry door before luncheon, Lydia blinked, looked at the young man’s earnest, freckled face, and answered in a much quieter voice than usual, that a walk in the courtyard would be very pleasant.

At 5:00 that afternoon, Verity sat at the small table in her own bedroom, shading the stonework of the new garden arch she had drawn with Hugh beside the yew hedge. A tap sounded at the door, lighter and more hesitant than a servant’s knock. When Verity called out to enter, Lydia stepped into the room. Lydia was already dressed in her evening gown of pale blue silk, and her fair hair was pinned up at the back, though one small curl near the left ear had escaped the tortoiseshell comb. In her hands, she carried neither a tangled sash nor an unironed handkerchief, but a square pasteboard box that belonged to Verity’s own modest wardrobe.

“I found your white lace fichu in the bottom of the large trunk when Susan was helping me look for my slippers,” Lydia said, stopping two paces inside the door, and setting the box neatly upon the chest at the foot of the bed. “It must have slipped under my evening petticoats when we packed at home. I asked Susan to run a warm iron over the edge because it was creased from the corner of the trunk.”

“Thank you, Lydia,” Verity said, setting her pencil down beside the sketchbook, and turning in her chair. “I wondered where it had gone.”