Right after dinner, I was going to stand up, tap my glass, and ask her to marry me in front of every person she loved. I’d rehearsed the speech in my truck so many times I could say it in my sleep. That Thursday, a site visit three hours north got canceled because of a storm, and the jeweler called the same morning to say the ring was resized and ready. It felt like the universe was clearing my afternoon for me.

I picked up the ring at noon. I bought a bunch of white tulips because Lauren worked from home on Thursdays, and I thought I’d surprise her with lunch and flowers and an afternoon off. I parked in the garage under our building at about half past two. I remember checking my reflection in the elevator and laughing at myself because I was nervous, and I wasn’t even proposing yet.

When I opened our front door, I heard voices. Lauren’s. Then Tessa’s. Then Bree’s. Wineglasses.

That loud, loose kind of laughter you only get on the second bottle. And my first thought, I swear, was, Oh, good. I can hide the ring before they see me. So I eased the door shut behind me quietly. And I stood in the little hallway by the coat closet, slipping the ring box deeper into my inside pocket.

That’s when Tessa said, “So, is Tuesday still happening?”

And Lauren said, “Every Tuesday. Yoga, remember?”

And they all laughed like that was the funniest thing in the world. I didn’t understand it yet. I actually smiled standing there because I thought I was about to hear some dumb inside joke.

Then Bree said, “Wait. Does Owen still not know?”

And my girlfriend of four years said, “I’ve been cheating on him for a year, and he still thinks I’m perfect.”

You know how people say time slows down? It doesn’t. It just goes quiet. I could hear the refrigerator humming. I could hear my own pulse in my ears.

I could hear Tessa snort into her glass and say, “You’re evil.”

Like it was a compliment.

And I could hear Lauren say, “I’m not evil. I’m efficient. Owen’s the stable one. Mr. Tuesday’s the fun one. Why would I pick?”

But that wasn’t the worst thing I heard in that hallway. Not even close.

Bree, sweet, clueless Bree, leaned forward. “Okay. But who is he? You never tell us his name.”

And Lauren said, “Nope. He’s Mr. Tuesday. That’s all you get. He’s taken. So it’s complicated.”

Tessa made a little sound, like she knew exactly who he was. Then Lauren held up her wrist.

“He’s sweet, though. He got me this. And here’s the funny part: he bought the exact same bracelet for his fiancée the same week, because he’s too lazy to come up with two different gifts.”