Her father made a small sound of protest.

“But I have read most of it. The oldest book goes back further than anyone in the village can remember. I began reading it when I was a girl because I liked the names, and I have never quite stopped.”

She sat down on the end of the sofa, the only part of it not covered in books, and pushed her wet hair behind her ears.

“What is it you want to know about Briar Cross, sir? The family has not set foot in this parish in my lifetime.”

He was quiet for a moment, looking into the fire. The wind threw a handful of rain against the glass, like gravel.

“There was a daughter of the house,” he said at last. “Lady Sophia, the old duke’s aunt. She left Briar Cross when she was very young and was never spoken of again. I’m told she married in this church.”

Harriet sat very still. She had not expected that name. Not today, not from a stranger in a muddy coat. She was aware of her father beside the fire.

His head turned toward her, waiting. She was aware of the gentleman’s eyes on her face. She made her voice ordinary.

“She did,” she said. “Everyone in Hollowcombe knows that story, or a version of it. She ran away from the great house with the village schoolmaster a long lifetime ago. And her father never forgave her. They say he had her portrait turned to face the wall of the long gallery so that no one would have to look at her again. They say it is still facing the wall.”

She paused.

“That is the kind of thing they say about Dukes in Hollowcombe.”

“And what do you say, Miss Wickridge?”

She looked at him. She was cold and wet, and she was more disturbed than she wished to be. And perhaps that made her blunter than she would otherwise have been.

“I say the family at Briar Cross has had its back to this village for as long as that portrait has had its face to the wall,” she said. “The old Duke never came here once. His agent came at Michaelmas to collect what was owed and went away again. And now there is a new Duke whom no one has ever seen, and I expect he will be the same. He will sit in London and believe whichever story is told him most prettily.”

Her father said, “Harriet,” in a mild voice. But Mr. Fairlie did not seem offended. That small movement came again at the corner of his mouth, and this time it stayed a little longer.

“Perhaps he would rather have a plain story than a pretty one,” he said.

“Then he should come and ask for it himself,” said Harriet, “instead of sending gentlemen to write histories.”

She heard how that sounded and felt her face warm.

“I beg your pardon. That was rude. You’re not to blame for the Duke.”