Elena did not know what to say to that, so she said nothing and simply stayed beside him, which seemed to matter more than any words could have.

It was nearly an hour later when the trouble began. A young nobleman named Caldwell, flushed with wine and surrounded by a few friends, eager to laugh at his jokes, sauntered toward their corner of the room with a cruel curl to his mouth.

“Well, well,” Caldwell said loudly enough for a dozen people to hear. “The merchant’s daughter has found herself a seat beside the Duke. How fortunate for a girl with no title to land in the lap of nobility. Perhaps you planned the fall, Miss Whitmore. A clever way to climb above your station.”

Laughter rippled through his circle of friends. Elena felt her face burn, humiliation twisting into anger in her chest. But before she could respond, the Duke’s hand tightened hard on the arm of his wheelchair.

“That is enough,” Alaric said, his voice suddenly cold and sharp, cutting through the laughter like a blade. “You will not speak to her that way in my presence.”

Caldwell smirked, clearly unbothered by a man he no longer considered a threat.

“Forgive me, Your Grace. I only meant…”

“I know exactly what you meant,” Alaric interrupted, “and I am telling you for the last time to be silent.”

But Caldwell, emboldened by drink and the certainty that the Duke could do nothing more than sit and glare, leaned closer and said something low and mocking about Elena’s dress, about her father’s trade, about girls who did not belong in rooms like this one. It was the kind of comment designed to wound quietly where only she and Alaric could hear the worst of it.

Something in Alaric’s face changed completely. The careful, resigned mask he had worn for 3 years cracked apart, replaced by a fury Elena had not seen in him until that exact moment. His knuckles went white against the arms of his chair.

“Get away from her,” he said, and this time his voice shook the air around them.

Caldwell laughed again, turning to his friends as if sharing a private joke.

“What will you do, Your Grace? Wheel yourself at me?”

The room had gone quiet again, drawn by the rising tension. And in that silence, Alaric pushed himself forward with both hands against the arms of his chair. Elena reached for him instinctively, afraid he would fall, but he shook his head sharply, refusing her help. His jaw locked tight with effort and pain.

His legs trembled violently as he forced his weight onto them for the first time in 3 years. A gasp tore through the crowd. Someone dropped a glass, and the shatter of crystal on the floor seemed impossibly loud in the stunned silence that followed.