If a woman has been in love with her best friend for the whole of her life and he has been in love with her for most of his and the two of them agree to marry without either one knowing how the other truly feels, what exactly would you call them? Silly perhaps or clueless? Maybe both. I will let you decide. But first, you ought to know what happened on their wedding day.

May Dawson was not supposed to drop the ring. No, she was not. She was supposed to follow through just as they had planned and they had been planning for months now. Every detail of it. Down to the flowers on the pews and the hymn her mother had insisted upon.

This was the day both families had been waiting for and May Dawson gave every one of them the shock of their lives. The ring struck the chapel floor with a sound far too small for what it meant and before anyone could think to pick it up, May had turned from the altar and was walking away. Not slowly either. She gathered her skirts in both hands and went down the side aisle past the startled faces in the pews and disappeared into the long corridor that ran along the chapel wall. Her mother hurrying after her and Henry, poor Henry, simply stood there at the altar with his hand still half raised as though she might yet come back and take it.

Both sides of the family turned to look at one another. The Dawsons on one side and the Dukes’ relations on the other. Each wondering whether the other knew something they did not. The priest looked down at the ring on the floor and then up at the Duke as if hoping someone might tell him what came next in the service. Nobody did.

George Lindley stood beside him and did not say a word. He had grown up alongside Henry and May since they were children and he did not need to. He simply looked at Henry and it was the kind of look that says, ‘I told you so.’ The look of a man who had warned his friend more than once to stop playing games and tell that girl the truth because Henry was the Duke and a Duke with a reputation, the kind mothers warned their daughters about. His family’s estate office managed every street they owned in London and it depended on men who would trust him with their money. Men like that do not trust a rake.

The quickest way for Henry to look respectable was to take a wife, and he could have chosen any woman in London. Instead, he went to May, his oldest and dearest friend, who had sat at the desk beneath his office window most mornings for years, helping with the leases. He asked her to help him with one thing more. One year, he told her, they would marry, he would mend his name, and when the year was over, they would part quietly and kindly, and she would be free.

A practical arrangement between friends, he said. Nothing more. What he did not tell her was that he had loved her for years, and that he dressed it up as a favor, because a favor can be refused without breaking a man’s heart. And what May did not tell him when she said yes, was that she loved him, too, and that she let him believe she was only being a good friend, because a good friend can walk away at the end of a year without anyone knowing what it cost her.