“She’s the oldest,” he told me. “Danny’s still a kid. If something happens to me, she and Lorraine will make the right decisions.”

I didn’t think much about it at the time. I should have. Remember that detail, because it mattered far more than anybody sitting at that table realized.

By October, I knew I wanted to marry her. Truthfully, I’d probably known for a while, but I’m a read-the-whole-contract kind of guy, so I’d taken my time. I wanted to do it right, and to me, doing it right meant asking her father first.

One night after closing, I stayed behind to help Frank count the cash drawer. When we were finished, I told him there was something I wanted to ask. He didn’t even look up from the bills. He just said, “About time.”

Then he laughed so hard he had to sit down on a bucket. He gave me his blessing right there, leaning against the oak counter his grandfather had built. And then he did something I didn’t expect.

He went into the back room and came out carrying a small wooden Christmas ornament. It was a carving of the hardware store, small enough to fit in my palm, painted, chipped, and obviously very old. His grandfather had carved it for Christmas the year the store opened. It had hung on the Delaney family Christmas tree every year since.

Frank turned it over and showed me a thin seam along the bottom.

“My grandfather hid my grandmother’s ring in here,” he said. “Christmas Eve, 1951. She had to break the thing open to find it. He glued it back together himself.”

Then he looked at me. “I want you to use it.”

I’m not somebody who gets emotional easily. I had to go stand by the paint mixer for a minute.

So that was the plan. On Christmas Eve, after dinner and presents, when everyone was gathered around the tree with pie and coffee, Frank would ask Brielle to take down the old ornament while he told its story, the way he did every year. Except this time, the ring inside would be mine. Lorraine was in on it. Danny was in on it. My mother was coming over for dessert. The only person who didn’t know was Brielle.

I spent all of November arranging everything else. For Lorraine, I tracked down her late mother’s sewing machine, the one she’d sold at a yard sale twenty years earlier and regretted selling every day since. I found it through a collector in Ohio and spent three weekends restoring it.

For Frank, I went to the county historical society and searched its archives until I found the original newspaper photograph from the day the store opened. His grandfather stood in the doorway with his white shirt sleeves rolled up. I had it printed and framed in reclaimed oak.

For Brielle, besides the ring, I’d booked a week in Charleston, South Carolina, for the spring. She’d talked about Charleston since our second date.