Her fingers tightened on the brush.
“I have spent 3 years guarding a house against another loss,” he said. “And somewhere in that silence, you made me wish to live in it again.”
“Rowan,” she whispered, surprising them both.
He took a single step nearer.
“I love you.”
Her eyes filled, but she held his gaze.
“I have tried very hard not to love you. Not because of Caroline or because you have been unkind, because I know what this world will call me if I believe such a love can belong to me.”
“And does it?”
“Yes,” she said. “But can it live anywhere other than this yard? Can it survive when you must introduce me as more than the woman who cares for your horse?”
The answer he wanted to give was yes. The answer he could give truthfully was more difficult. He had never married outside his station. He understood neither all the practical challenges she would face nor the full extent of what his family might demand. He could not make her safe by promising the world would change.
“I will find out what the choice requires,” he said, “and I will not pretend it requires nothing.”
She looked disappointed, and yet after a moment, grateful. A false assurance would have been easier to say. It would have been harder to live with.
Before the month ended, three messages arrived. Mr. Talbot wished to reconsider the grazing contract. Lady Augusta Ashworth, Rowan’s aunt, expressed alarm at reports that he had employed a woman once dismissed by Vane, and was defending her publicly. A family that had offered Hugh a summer visit now wrote that its plans were uncertain. Mrs. Finch saw the letters on the hall table.
“You are beginning to pay for this, Your Grace,” she said.
“For uncovering an old injustice?”
“For refusing to let other people decide which injustices are worth uncovering.”
Rowan laid a hand on Lady Augusta’s unopened second letter. She was coming to Ashcombe Hall. She would bring the whole weight of family expectation with her, and he could no longer imagine that Lydia would remain untouched by its arrival.
Lady Augusta arrived on a clear morning in late March with two trunks and an opinion she did not intend to conceal. She had been Rowan’s aunt long enough to consider frankness a duty. And her affection for him was genuine. That made her opposition harder to dismiss.
“You are 40,” she told him over tea, “and have responsibilities larger than any private inclination. You have your tenants, the household, your brother’s future. The wife of a duke must be prepared for duties that your Miss Hartwell has never been allowed to learn.”
“Lydia is not a child who must be graded for admission.”
“I did not say she was. But affection will not make a hostile drawing room welcoming. Several of our relations will refuse the acquaintance. One family had thought you might consider their daughter. Your brother will lose opportunities if everyone fears being drawn into this quarrel.”
“I made no promise to that family or its daughter.”
“That is fortunate. It does not remove the consequences.”
Rowan knew Lady Augusta was describing possibilities rather than issuing an idle threat. She held influence within the family and could choose not to lend it. Her objections mixed genuine concern with the prejudices of a lifetime. He rejected the prejudice. He could not entirely reject the concern.