“Ask the girl.” Gideon had supposed he meant ask the Kennesley girl to marry you. He had done it. He had given his word and kept it. And still he did not understand.

Why had his father chosen her? The candle guttered. Down in the kitchen, he supposed, the lamb was asleep by the range. Gideon put the button back in his pocket and went up the stairs in the dark without a light, as he always did, because he knew every step of this house, and none of it had ever felt like home.

The rain went on for three days, and Hester learned the house. She learned it from Mrs. Gwatkin, the housekeeper, who had come to Wigmore as a stillroom maid 40 years before, and remembered both the boys in their cradles, and who said within an hour of their first proper conversation,

“You’ll not mind me saying, miss, that you’re the first one he’s let into the kitchen with him since Lord Thomas died.”

She learned that the Duke never wore a greatcoat, not in rain or frost or the January snow, that he had never worn one since he was 10 years old, that his valet had stopped laying one out years ago, and Mrs. Gwatkin had not stopped scolding about it. She learned that he never rode on the ridge, though it was his own land and the best riding in the county. And she learned that he kept a horn button in his waistcoat pocket, and rolled it in his fingers when he was troubled. And that he was troubled most of the time.

“Lady Harriet never did ask what it was,” said Mrs. Gwatkin. “She keeps the household books and the home farm books and the wool books, and she’s a wonderful hand at a column of figures, but she never asked him one thing about himself in 20 years.”

Hester learned the stables from Jenkin, the old head groom, who was deaf in one ear and had to be shouted at, and who took to her on the second morning when she went to look at his mare’s cracked heel, and told him to try a poultice of bran and comfrey. Jenkin showed her the tack room and the loose boxes and the gate into the paddock, and on the gatepost, cut deep and square into the oak, were the letters TP.

“Lord Thomas!” shouted Jenkin because he always shouted. “Carved his letters on everything he did. Every gate on the estate. Had a little knife his grandfather gave him and he couldn’t pass a bit of wood. The old Duke would rage at him for it. You’ll find TP on half the doors in the county. Miss, if you look.”

Hester stood with her fingers in the cut letters.

“Where was he going, Jenkin? The night he died.”

Jenkin’s face changed.

“I was told never to speak of that nightmare.”

“By whom?”

“By the old duke.”

He looked at the gatepost, not at her.

“And his lordship took it so hard. He was a little lad, you see, and they’d had words, him and his father, at dinner, and he went running out of the house in his temper. And the old duke stood in this very yard with the snow coming down and said for all of us to hear, ‘He went out after you,’ meaning Lord Thomas went out after the boy and the young lord heard it.”

The old man rubbed his face.

“He’s been carrying it ever since, miss. You can see it in him.”

Hester said nothing for a moment. Then she said plainly because she wanted to fix it in her own mind.