Horses passed through a junction by the dozen every week, and he didn’t study the riders unless they were buying or selling. Denning didn’t care whether that was true. He wanted the show of an answer. And Whitlock’s honest uncertainty looked to him like defiance.

“A man in your spot sees everything that moves through this town,” Denning said, stepping closer. “I’d think hard before deciding you don’t remember.”

“Son, I’m not deciding anything,” Whitlock said. “I keep no ledger of that sort.”

Denning’s open hand cracked across his jaw, hard enough to spin him halfway around and slam him against a stall rail. Two stable hands who might have stepped in froze when Denning’s other hand came to rest, loose and unhurried on the grip of his revolver. He didn’t draw. He just reminded the whole yard what was possible.

“Try again,” Denning said, still smiling. “I’ve got plenty of patience today.”

Whitlock, blood at the corner of his mouth, offered the only true thing he had.

“I don’t know.”

Denning studied him, decided the old man was either honest or too stubborn to break, and walked off as though the whole exchange had cost him nothing, which in his own mind it hadn’t. 11 people had watched an old man get struck over an answer he didn’t have. That was about to change before sunset. Butch Cassidy, the Sundance Kid, Ben Kilpatrick, Will Carver, and Kid Curry rode into Larksburg Junction a little after 5 that evening, weary and unremarkable, hunting for exactly the sort of quiet livery stop that had just stopped being quiet.

They found the yard buzzing with low, nervous talk, stable hands sweeping in silence, and Amos Whitlock perched on an overturned crate with a wet cloth pressed to his swelling jaw. Carver asked, calm and unhurried, what had happened. It took under a minute of listening to a stable boy before all five understood what kind of afternoon the town had endured.

“Fancy dresser,” the boy said. “Fast hands. Asked Mr. Whitlock about five riders. One uncommon tall,” he said. “Another real quiet. Mr. Whitlock didn’t know a thing.”

“Hit him anyway. Seemed like he just wanted to.”

Ben glanced at Sundance.

“Uncommon tall,” he repeated.

“Real quiet,” Sundance said, not looking up from where he crouched beside Whitlock, checking the old man’s jaw with careful fingers. “That’s close enough to two of us that it can’t be chance.”

“Somebody’s hunting us by name,” Butch said. “And paying a man in a suit like that to do the asking.”

Whitlock, hearing more than he was meant to, looked up sharply.

“You’re the ones he’s after.”

“Looks that way,” Butch said. “And he took it out on you for not answering fast enough. That’s a debt we owe, not you.”

“I don’t want trouble following back into my yard,” Whitlock said.

“Wasn’t your trouble to begin with,” Curry said, his voice low. “A man who hits an old man for an honest answer doesn’t need permission to come bother me.”