“Class,” Mrs. Patterson announced, her voice carrying to every corner of the room, “I’ve made an interesting observation. It seems we have someone among us who has a special interest in the piano.”
Lily’s stomach dropped. She shook her head slightly, but Mrs. Patterson continued.
“Oh, yes. I’ve noticed how you watch the other students play. How you stare at the piano every single class. You’re practically fascinated by it.”
“I just… I like music,” Lily said quietly.
“Do you?” Mrs. Patterson’s eyebrows went up in exaggerated surprise. “Well, then this is wonderful because I believe that every student who shows interest should have an opportunity to demonstrate their abilities. Wouldn’t you agree, class?”
A few students nodded uncertainly. They didn’t know where this was going, but they could feel something strange in the air.
“So, Lily…” Mrs. Patterson gestured toward the piano bench. “Why don’t you sit down and play something for us? After all, if you’re so interested in the piano, you must have something to share.”
Lily’s face went pale.
“I… I don’t…”
“Oh, come now. Don’t be modest.” Mrs. Patterson’s voice had an edge to it now. “You watched the other students so intently. Surely you’ve learned something. Unless…” She paused dramatically. “Unless you were just pretending to be interested, because that would be dishonest, wouldn’t it?”
The other students shifted in their seats. Some of them looked uncomfortable. They might not have liked Lily, might not have even noticed her before, but this felt wrong somehow. Even Timothy, Mrs. Patterson’s star pupil, frowned a little.
But Rachel, who’d been taking piano lessons since she was five and thought she was the best pianist in the school, smiled. She’d seen the way Lily looked at the piano. She didn’t like it.
“Go on, Lily,” Mrs. Patterson said, her voice sickeningly sweet now. “Show us what you can do. Everyone’s waiting.”
Lily looked at the piano bench. Then at the classroom door. For a moment, it seemed like she might run. Her whole body was tense like a bird ready to take flight. Her hands were trembling at her sides.
“I really don’t think…” Lily started to say.
“Lily.” Mrs. Patterson’s voice turned sharp. “In my classroom, when a teacher asks you to do something, you do it. Now sit down at that piano.”
The room was completely silent now. Even the clock on the wall seemed to tick more quietly. Every eye was on Lily, watching and waiting. Some kids looked sorry for her. Others just wanted to see what would happen.
And Mrs. Patterson stood there with her arms crossed, absolutely certain of how this would go. The poor girl would sit down, maybe poke at the keys randomly, prove that she had no talent at all, and learn an important lesson about her place in this school. It was perfect. It would remind all the students that Mrs. Patterson could see right through anyone who tried to pretend they were something they weren’t. Lily stood frozen for what felt like forever.
Then slowly, she walked to the piano bench. She sat down carefully, her small frame looking even smaller against the grand piano. Her worn sneakers barely reached the pedals. Her faded sweater looked even more shabby next to the piano’s polished elegance. Mrs. Patterson smiled triumphantly.
“Whenever you’re ready, dear. We’re all waiting to hear what you can do.”
Behind her, Rachel whispered to the girl next to her, “This is going to be embarrassing.”
Timothy looked down at his desk, unable to watch what was about to happen. The boy who sat in the middle row, the one Mrs. Patterson had sighed at for making a mistake, felt his stomach twist. He knew exactly what this felt like. And in the back corner where Lily usually sat, her empty desk seemed to echo with all the days she’d spent trying to be invisible. Lily’s hands hovered over the keys.