“Is that what you call this?”

“I still haven’t decided what to call it.”

They spent almost an hour building a story simple enough to remember. According to the official version, they had met in London during a dinner. They met again months later in Bath and began writing to each other shortly after. Henry refused to accept that he had sent romantic letters and Elizabeth decided that was perfectly consistent with his character. When they returned to the family, they discovered that their preparation had served very little purpose.

“Who fell in love first?” asked Henry’s mother.

Elizabeth calmly picked up her cup.

“Henry.”

He nearly choked on his tea.

“Me?”

Elizabeth looked at him with a smile.

“Dear, you don’t have to be ashamed.”

Aunt Eleanor let out a laugh.

“I knew it had to have been him.”

Henry looked at Elizabeth as if he were seriously considering breaking an engagement that had never existed.

For the rest of the morning, however, they began to handle themselves better. Every time someone asked an unexpected question, one of them would invent an answer and the other would continue it. By lunchtime, they had a story so complete that Elizabeth began to fear they might end up believing it themselves.

Henry also turned out to be much less unpleasant company than she had assumed. She saw him stop in the hallway to ask a maid about her sick mother, and later he personally accompanied Lady Dorothea to the garden because the old lady refused to use the butler’s arm. Elizabeth was watching them from the terrace when Henry returned.

“You’re staring at me.”

“I was looking at your grandmother.”

“I was right next to her.”

“That was just bad luck.”

Henry smiled. Elizabeth then discovered something she hadn’t noticed the day before. When he truly smiled, he stopped looking like such a serious man and became dangerously pleasant. She decided to look toward the garden.

That afternoon, a much more urgent problem appeared. Lady Dorothea was examining Elizabeth’s left hand when she frowned.

“Where is your ring?”

Elizabeth pulled her hand away.

“My ring?”

“The engagement one.”

Henry, who was sitting across from them, stopped reading. Elizabeth searched for an answer.

“It’s being resized.”

Henry raised his head. Lady Dorothea looked at him.

“Didn’t you check the size before buying it?”

“Naturally I did,” Henry replied.

Elizabeth glared at him.

“Then why is it being resized?”

Henry remained silent. Elizabeth quickly intervened:

“Because I wanted to make a small change to it.”

Lady Dorothea seemed satisfied.

“I want to see it before my birthday.”

“Of course,” Henry replied.

Elizabeth waited until the old lady left the room before turning to him.

“Of course?”

“Something had to be said.”

“And what do you plan to put on my finger?”

“We’ll find something.”

“Do you have many engagement rings hidden around the house?”

Henry stood up.

“Surprisingly, no.”

The only solution was to visit the town jeweler before the weather worsened. Henry explained that they needed a simple ring for two days, and the man, who had evidently already heard the news of the engagement, greeted them with such an enthusiastic smile that Elizabeth realized debunking that story was going to be much more complicated than anticipated. The jeweler placed several pieces on the counter.

“This would be lovely for the young lady.”

Henry picked up one with small stones around it and shook his head.

“Too flashy.”

Elizabeth looked at him.

“I didn’t know you had opinions about my jewelry.”

“I am supposed to be the man who chose your ring. I should have one.”