Noah felt his heart ache for him.
“That must have been terrible.”
“It was,” Dr. Holloway said. “And for many years, I blamed everyone but myself: I blamed the audience for making me nervous; I blamed the critics for putting too much pressure on me; I blamed my teachers for not preparing me properly. But eventually, I realized the truth.”
“What was the truth?”
“That I had forgotten why I was there. I had gotten so caught up in what other people expected of me, in what success was supposed to look like, that I forgot about the only thing that mattered: the music. I was not on that stage to prove anything to anyone. I was there to share something beautiful with the world, and I let my fear take that away from me.”
He looked at Noah with an intensity he had never seen before.
“I do not want that to happen to you. You have something I never had: you have a connection to the music that goes deeper than technique, deeper than training, deeper than anything I can teach you. When you play, you are not performing. You are telling the truth, and the truth does not care about nerves, or fear, or what the critics might say.”
Noah thought about his words. He thought about all the times he had played when no one was listening: at the church, alone in the back room; in his room at the academy with only the walls as his audience; at the audition, when he closed his eyes and forgot about the judges. Those were the times when the music was purest, when he was not trying to impress anyone or prove anything, when he was just Noah, playing the piano, letting the melody speak for him.
“How do I get back to that?” Noah asked. “How do I forget about the audience and just play?”
Dr. Holloway smiled.
“You already know how. You did it at your audition: you closed your eyes and went somewhere else, somewhere the judges could not reach you, somewhere the fear could not follow.” He stood up and walked to the window of his studio. “When you walk onto that stage at Carnegie Hall, you will see thousands of people: famous musicians, important critics, reporters from every major publication. And yes, it will be terrifying. But here is what I want you to remember.” He turned back to face him. “None of them matter. Not the critics, not the reporters, not even me. The only person who matters is your father. Play for him. Play as if he is sitting in the front row watching you keep the promise you made to him. Play as if you are back in that small apartment in Jamaica, sitting on his lap while he shows you the keys for the first time.”
Noah felt tears spring to his eyes.
“I miss him,” Noah whispered. “Every single day.”
“I know you do,” Dr. Holloway said gently. “And that is exactly why your music touches people the way it does: because it comes from love, from loss, from the deepest parts of your heart. No amount of training can create that. It is a gift, your father’s gift to you.”