Noah felt his face grow hot. His hands were shaking slightly. He wanted to say something, to defend himself, but the words would not come.

“My advice to you,” Dr. Holloway continued, “is to find something more suitable for your level. Perhaps a community choir. Or maybe some local group that performs at events. Something simple. Something you can handle.”

The younger woman judge looked away; she seemed embarrassed. The older woman was staring at the table, saying nothing. Noah sat at the piano, frozen. He had expected that getting into this school would be difficult. He had expected to face tough judges and hard questions.

But he had not expected this: he had not expected to be dismissed after thirty seconds; he had not expected to be told that he was not good enough to even try. A voice inside him said: Stand up. Walk away. Accept it. Go home and forget about this place.

But another voice, a deeper voice, said something else. It said: No. No. He had not come all this way to give up after half a minute. He had not spent three years practicing on cardboard keyboards and borrowed pianos just to be told to join a community choir. He had not carried his father’s dream in his heart all this time just to let it die in this room.

Noah did not stand up. He did not walk away. He stayed on the bench. Dr. Holloway was already looking at his papers, ready to call the next person.

“Excuse me,” Noah said.

He looked up, surprised.

“Yes?”

“I would like to play more.”

Dr. Holloway frowned.

“I told you we have heard enough.”

“You heard thirty seconds,” Noah said. His voice was quiet but steady. “You heard me make one mistake on a piano I have never touched before. You did not hear what I can really do.”

The room was very quiet. The other judges were staring at him now. Dr. Holloway’s frown deepened.

“young man,” he said. “We have many more people to see today. We cannot spend extra time on every candidate who thinks they deserve a second chance.”

“I am not asking for a second chance,” Noah said. “I am asking for a first one. A real one. Sixty seconds. That is all. Give me sixty seconds to show you what I can do. If you still think I am not good enough after that, I will leave and never bother you again.”

Dr. Holloway stared at him. For a long moment, no one spoke. Noah could hear his own heart beating in his chest. The older woman judge leaned toward Dr. Holloway.

“Richard,” she said softly. “Perhaps we could give him a minute. It would not hurt.”

Dr. Holloway did not answer right away. He was still looking at Noah with those cold, judging eyes. He met his gaze and did not look away. Finally, he let out a short breath.

“Fine,” he said. “Sixty seconds. But I want to see what you can really do with something simple. None of this Chopin business. Let us see how you handle basic material.”