“Your husband signed before he disappeared,” Pike said. “This building isn’t yours anymore.”
On the road outside, wagon wheels ground against stones while the town continued its ordinary business, unaware of what the papers might reveal.
Clara leaned closer. Beneath Samuel’s name stood a signature so familiar it made her breath catch. Her father had always signed with his left hand after losing two fingers in a sawmill accident. This signature slanted the other way.
Clara put her palm on the paper before Pike could reclaim it. “That’s not my father’s writing,” she said. The room grew quiet for a different reason. A few patrons remembered Samuel Whitcomb’s crooked letters and the thick black line he drew beneath his name. Here the letters flowed elegantly, and there was no line at all.
Pike folded his arms. “A county recorder says it’s real. A girl pouring drinks says it isn’t. I know which one a judge will believe.”
Ruth knew the danger of arguing with a man already protected by a badge. Mercy Creek sat two days from the nearest circuit court. The deputy marshal served as town constable when the elected sheriff was away, which was most of the time. Men like Pike counted on distance, fatigue, and the simple fact that poor people could seldom afford to stop working long enough to contest a document.
“Then we shall take it to a judge,” Ruth said.
“Tomorrow you’ll take your belongings out,” Pike replied. “The demolition wagon arrives Friday.”
He reached for Clara again. Ruth raised the revolver, not at his chest but toward the ceiling beam directly above the bar. “Take your hand away.”
Pike’s smile hardened. His companions spread out, blocking the rear door and the stairway to the rooms above. A gray bearded teamster near the stove stood halfway, sat when another rider rested a hand on his holster.
The piano remained silent. Outside, wind lifted a corner of the sale notice against the window. Ruth could see the date printed beside the supposed signature: October 14, 1878. On that date Samuel had not been in Mercy Creek at all. He had been three hundred miles away, and Ruth possessed a letter proving it. The letter was upstairs, behind Clara’s childhood portrait.
Ruth lowered the gun a fraction. “Clara, bring down your father’s picture.” She spoke as she might have asked for more coffee, hoping Pike would hear only an ordinary household request. Clara heard the urgency beneath it. She moved toward the stairs, and the broad shouldered rider named Doss stepped into her path.
“Nobody goes upstairs until we search the place,” he said.
“You have no warrant,” Ruth answered.
“We have a deputy waiting outside,” Doss said, and turned the lock on the street door.
The men were too confident. Ruth began to understand that the false deed was only one part of their plan. If they could provoke her into firing, the deputy could arrest her for assault. Clara would be left alone, and the saloon could be taken without a court hearing. Ruth felt the weight of Samuel’s revolver and set it flat on the bar again.