Clara was less patient. “They paid him the night Pa disappeared. Doesn’t that tell us something?”
“It tells us we must ask why,” Ruth replied.
They carried the receipt to Judge Mercer, who compared its amount with several public expense claims. Vale had billed the county for escorting a prisoner to Cheyenne on the same date. No prisoner was named. Mercer ordered the jail register produced and instructed his clerk to preserve certified copies of every relevant entry.
Meanwhile Pike arrived at the boardinghouse with a basket of imported oranges. He spoke pleasantly to Mrs. Hart and asked whether Clara’s wrist had recovered. Ruth met him on the porch and refused the gift.
“I meant no lasting offense,” Pike said. “Perhaps we’ve been too hasty. Sell the spring to High Ridge, and the saloon is yours again. We might even offer the young lady a respectable position.”
“A respectable man wouldn’t threaten a young woman to make her mother sign,” Ruth answered.
Pike’s smile vanished. “You’ll get nothing if you keep making trouble.”
Through the parlor window Clara watched him depart. She noticed that he did not ride toward the depot. Clara told her mother, opened her account book to a page she had marked months earlier. An unfamiliar railroad charge appeared on the same date as Vale’s payment. It carried a name neither woman had heard before: Margaret Bell.
Gideon had told them about a vanished ferry keeper named Margaret Bell. Jonas found Samuel’s broken wagon wheel near her abandoned tollhouse, and Ruth could no longer stay away.
Ruth wanted to ride to the tollhouse immediately. Clara insisted they take the constable and Gideon instead of marching into an abandoned building after dark.
At sunrise the four crossed the old river bridge. The tollhouse stood on a rise overlooking the water, its roof half stripped and one window boarded. Inside, rodents had chewed the blankets and rain had softened the floorboards. Gideon found a groove in the mud where heavy wheels had been dragged toward the bank.
The constable explored the cellar while Ruth and Clara searched the main room. Clara noticed pencil marks on the underside of a shelf, numbers arranged in short groups. She recognized freight car references, not ordinary household accounts.
The numbers matched those on the unexplained railroad charges. The constable returned with a rusted strongbox, empty except for a leather strap and a strip of blue cloth. Ruth remembered Samuel wearing a blue scarf when he left. She held the cloth close but resisted the urge to conclude the worst.
Outside, Gideon found boot prints beneath the boarded window. Somebody had visited recently and removed an object from beneath the floor. An empty square of clean wood marked where a box or parcel had stood.
Clara knelt, studying the nail holes. “This shelf was moved after the dust settled,” she said. “Whoever took the papers knew exactly where to look.”
A voice answered from the doorway. “I did.” An elderly woman in a faded green traveling coat stood beside the constable’s horse. “My name is Margaret Bell, and if you want the truth about Samuel Whitcomb, you’ll have to hear what I did first.”