Chapter 4

But I had never wanted Mason back. Not after what happened with him. I set the papers down and forced myself to breathe.

“Nathan, listen to me. Mason is not some harmless ex I occasionally think about. He is the reason I stopped answering unknown numbers. He is the reason I changed jobs in my twenties. I didn’t tell you because I was ashamed that I stayed with him as long as I did.”

Nathan’s eyes narrowed slightly.

“What happened?”

I looked at Erin. Then at the photo again. The side entrance of Alana’s building was visible behind me, along with a blue sedan parked near the alley. I hadn’t noticed it that day. There had been nothing unusual about it.

But now I remembered something. When I left Alana’s place Monday morning, that same blue sedan had been parked across the street. I had assumed it belonged to one of her neighbors. My mouth went dry.

“There was a car,” I said. “A blue sedan. It was there when I arrived Friday. It was there Sunday. And it was still there this morning.”

Erin reached for the photograph.

“Can you identify the make?”

“I don’t know cars well enough for that.”

Nathan leaned forward.

“Rachel, why would Mason be watching you?”

I met his eyes.

“Because he used to do things like this.”

Silence filled the room. For the first time since I walked in, Nathan’s calm expression cracked. Not into forgiveness. Not into trust. Into concern.

I turned back to the letter and read the final paragraph more carefully. Mason’s words blurred at first, then came into focus. He claimed he had been trying to “protect Nathan from becoming the next person Rachel destroys.” But beneath that was a handwritten note in dark ink. It wasn’t addressed to Nathan. It was addressed to me.

Rachel, before you tell him what you told him about me, ask yourself why I kept the recording.

My breath caught. Nathan stood up slowly.

“What recording?”

I looked at the bottom of the envelope. There was one more item inside. A small sealed evidence sleeve. And written across it, in Mason’s unmistakable handwriting, were four words that made my hands start shaking all over again.

THE NIGHT SHE RAN.

The evidence sleeve felt almost weightless in my hand, but I couldn’t make myself tear it open. Nathan was standing across from me now, one hand braced against the back of the sofa. Erin had gone very still beside the coffee table, watching both of us as if she knew one careless sentence could turn this room into something none of us could take back.

“The night she ran,” Nathan said. “What does that mean?”

I kept staring at Mason’s handwriting.

“It means he wants me to panic,” I said.

Nathan’s expression tightened.

“Rachel, that isn’t an answer.”

“No,” I said, looking up at him. “It’s the first honest answer I’ve given you in years.”