“Mr. Hale’s attorney has sent a formal notice,” she said. “They claim you have been making false statements about him and that you are trying to damage his reputation.”
I actually laughed. It was a small, broken sound, but I couldn’t help it. Mason had always been best at taking the thing he was doing and placing it in someone else’s hands.
“He has an attorney?” I asked.
“He has representation,” Erin said carefully. “And they’ve included material they intend to use if this becomes public.”
Nathan looked at the evidence sleeve.
“The recording.”
“Partly.” Erin turned her phone toward us. “There are screenshots, photos, and a statement from Mason alleging that Rachel contacted him repeatedly in recent months.”
“I didn’t.”
“There is also a photo of you outside Alana’s building,” she said. “And another from Friday morning.”
My stomach dropped.
“Friday morning?” I repeated.
Erin enlarged the image. It showed me outside a coffee shop near my office, carrying my laptop bag. The photo had been taken from across the street. In the corner, barely visible behind a parked delivery van, was Nathan’s car.
I looked at him. He stared at the screen, confused.
“I wasn’t there Friday morning. I was at work.”
“I know,” I said.
But Mason didn’t know that. He had seen the car. He had taken the photo. He had assumed Nathan was watching me.
And suddenly, Nathan’s quiet behavior after the dinner made terrible sense in a way I hadn’t considered before. His distance. The stopped calls. His refusal to ask where I was going. Mason had not just been following me. He had been watching Nathan too.
“He wants us to turn on each other,” I said.
Nathan looked at the printed messages again.
“He already did.”
That hurt because it was true. I had spent three days blaming Nathan for abandoning me, while Nathan sat in this house wondering whether I had been lying to him for months. Mason had placed just enough evidence between us to make our worst assumptions feel reasonable.
Chapter 6
Erin picked up the envelope.
“There’s something else. The letter references a meeting tomorrow morning.”
“A meeting with who?” Nathan asked.
Erin’s jaw tightened.
“Mason’s attorney wants Rachel to sign a statement retracting any implication that Mason has harassed her. In exchange, they claim they will stop contacting Nathan.”
I stared at her.
“They’re offering to leave him alone if I say nothing happened?”
“They are framing it as a clarification,” Erin said. “But yes.”
Nathan stood again.
“Absolutely not.”
For the first time since I walked in, something steady moved through me.
“No,” I said.
Both of them turned toward me. Nathan’s anger was immediate.
“Rachel, you don’t have to prove anything to this man.”
“I’m not proving anything to him.”
“Then what are you doing?”
I looked down at the photograph of Alana’s building. The blue sedan was barely visible near the alley. I had missed it before because I had been too busy convincing myself I was in control. But there was one detail I had not missed. The coffee cup in my hand.