Chapter 7

“What do we do?” Nathan asked.

The question surprised me. Not because he asked it, but because he was asking me. I looked at the papers spread across our coffee table: the fake messages, the photographs, the letter designed to make Nathan doubt me, and the recording Mason wanted me to fear.

“We stop reacting to what he wants,” I said. “We document everything.”

Erin gave a slight nod.

“That’s the right approach.”

I pointed to the text-message printouts.

“He says I contacted him Thursday night. What time?”

Erin checked the page.

“A little after ten.”

I felt something click into place. Thursday night, after Nathan left the restaurant, I had stayed with Alana and the others until nearly midnight. I remembered because one of the women from our group had insisted on taking a group picture outside the restaurant. We had all been standing under the awning, complaining about the cold, waiting for rides.

My stomach tightened, but this time it wasn’t from fear. It was from clarity.

“I wasn’t alone,” I said. “Not that night. Alana was there. So were six other people. They saw me.”

Nathan looked at the printout again.

“And earlier that day,” I continued, “I was at work until after six. My badge logs will show it. My calendar will show I was in meetings. If he has months of messages from me, then he has to prove where they came from.”

Erin’s expression sharpened.

“Do you still have the phone number he claims he was texting?”

I looked closer at the page. The number listed beneath my name was not mine. It looked close enough at first glance. Same area code. Similar pattern. But two digits were wrong.

I let out a breath that almost became a laugh.

“He didn’t even use my number.”

Nathan moved beside me, reading over my shoulder.

“How did I miss that?”

“Because he wanted you to read the words, not the details,” I said.

For the first time since I had walked through that front door, Nathan looked ashamed. His voice was barely above a whisper.

“And because I was already hurt enough to believe the worst.”

I wanted to stay angry. Part of me was angry. He had let Mason’s lies enter our home because I had given him every reason to question me. But the truth was more complicated than either of us wanted it to be.

“I hurt you,” I said. “What I said at dinner was cruel. I made you into a joke because I wanted everyone to think I was untouchable.”

Nathan’s eyes met mine.

“But Mason is not the consequence of what I did,” I added. “He is a man who has been waiting for an opening.”

Nathan nodded slowly.

“You’re right.”

My phone rang again. Alana. I answered immediately.

“Security got him out of the lobby,” she said. Her voice shook. “He kept saying he only wanted to make sure you were okay. Then he told them you were confused and that your husband was keeping you from him.”