The pressed violet slipped out of the old drawer and landed on the desk like a small purple warning. Alister Ashford, Duke of Hardcastle, stopped breathing for a moment. He had not seen that flower in 5 years, and he had been very careful never to look for it. Downstairs, the music of the grand ball still drifted through the halls. 300 guests were drinking his wine and praising his name.

Every mother in the room had pushed a daughter toward him that night, and every daughter had smiled the same smile. By midnight, a bishop and two earls had told him it was time to choose a duchess. He had slipped away to his study, claiming he needed air. Now, he held a flower that smelled of summer and old promises.

He lifted the violet carefully. The petals were thin as paper. Eleanor Whitmore had given it to him on the day he asked her to marry him in the garden behind her father’s house. She was a country doctor’s daughter with ink on her fingers, and she had laughed at him when he knelt down. Then, she had said yes. He remembered that yes better than anything else in his life.

Three months later, a letter had come. He still knew every word. Eleanor wrote that she had never truly loved him, that she had been dazzled by his title, and that she wished to be released. The handwriting was hers. The signature was hers.

He had read it standing in this very room, and something inside him had closed like a door. He had not written back. He had not ridden to her village. His pride would not allow it. And his mother, the Dowager Duchess Lavinia, had simply poured him a cup of tea and said, “Better to learn it now, my dear. That sort of girl always wants more than she says.”

Alister sat down slowly. For 5 years, he had believed that story. Tonight, for the first time, a cold question crept into his mind. Why had Eleanor, who could never tell a lie without blushing, written such a cold and careful letter?

A soft knock sounded. Pembroke, the old butler, entered with a tray and a worried face.

“Your Grace, the guests are asking for you. Shall I say you are unwell?”

“Say whatever you like,” Alister murmured.

Then, almost without meaning to, he asked, “Pembroke, do you remember Miss Whitmore?”

The old man’s hands trembled and the cups rattled on the tray.

“I do, Your Grace.”

“Do you know what became of her?”

Pembroke hesitated, glanced at the door, and spoke too quickly, the way a man does when he has carried a secret too long.