Alister felt the floor tilt.

“You what?”

“I told myself I was protecting you. I thought you would grieve for a season and then marry.”

Her voice broke.

“I was a proud and foolish woman.”

“There was more,” Eleanor said quietly. “Two months later I learned I was expecting a child. I wrote to you at once. I wrote again and again, every week for a whole spring. No answer ever came.”

“Because I destroyed them,” Lavinia said. “Your footman brought me every letter before it reached your desk. I burned the last one in my own sitting room.”

“My father died that winter,” Eleanor continued, her voice steady, though her hands were not. “A fever took him in 3 days. I sold his books to pay for the burial. I took in sewing. I grew vegetables. I told myself that you had read my letters and chosen silence and that I would never beg a man who did not want us.”

“I wanted you,” Alister said, and his voice cracked. “I wanted you every day.”

Lavinia stepped forward.

“I found out 2 years ago from a cousin who had passed through Thornby. I came to see for myself. I meant to leave. But the child ran to the door and held up a dandelion, and I could not go.”

She wiped her eyes.

“I have come every Tuesday since. I could not tell you, Alister. I was a coward.”

Alister walked to the fireplace and stood with his back to them both. When he finally spoke, his voice was low.

“You took 5 years from me, Mother. You took a father from that boy.”

“Yes,” Lavinia said.

She did not argue. It was somehow the worst thing of all. He turned to Eleanor.

“I will fix this. Tell me how. I will fix it.”

She shook her head gently with quiet sadness.

“You cannot give me back 5 years, Alister. You cannot give him back his first word or his first steps. An apology will not undo what has been done.”

“Go home,” Eleanor said. “Please, I need time.”

Alister bowed his head. He walked out into the cold, bright afternoon, and he did not look back.

The great hall of Hardcastle had never been so quiet. 40 relatives sat in carved chairs whispering, wondering why the duke had called them home on a Sunday morning. Then the dowager duchess stood up. She spoke plainly in a voice that carried to every corner. She told them about the false letter, the burned pages, and the child who had grown up without a father. She laid her ring of keys on the table, bowed to her son, and said she would live in the small dower house at the edge of the park, and would visit Thornby only when Eleanor allowed it.