“I would not do that if I were you.”

He spun around. An old woman stood at the gate, leaning on a walking stick, her eyes sharp as needles.

“I am Mrs. Hollis,” she said. “I know a rich man’s boots when I see them. If you have come to hurt that girl again, go back the way you came.”

“Again?”

Alister frowned.

“Madam, I have never hurt her. She was the one who…”

“Was she?”

Mrs. Hollis looked at him for a long moment. Her face changed. It was not anger he saw there now. It was fear.

“Today is Tuesday,” she said slowly. “Perhaps you should come back another day.”

“Why does the day matter?”

She did not answer. Her eyes slid to the hedge behind the cottage.

Alister followed her gaze and saw the corner of a black carriage hidden there, plain and unmarked, its horses resting in the shade. He turned back to the door. His hand was shaking, so he made a fist to steady it.

Then he lifted his hand to knock. His knuckles stopped an inch from the wood. A sound had floated out through the thin door, and it went through him like cold water.

Someone was singing. It was a soft, low voice, a little cracked with age, and it was singing a lullaby about a boat on a silver sea. Alister knew that song. He had not heard it since he was 4 years old. She had sat on his bed all night and sung it again and again until the sun came up. That woman was his mother.

He shook his head. It was impossible. The Dowager Duchess Lavinia had not left the Hardcastle estate in 11 years. She hated mud, hated villages, and above all hated anything small and poor.

She did not sing. Then the voice did something worse. It laughed.

Alister crept sideways to the window. A gap had been left between the curtain and the glass. He leaned in and looked. The room inside was tiny and warm. A fire crackled in a stone fireplace.

And on the rug in front of the fire, wearing her best gray silk gown and sitting right down on the floor like a girl, was the Dowager Duchess of Hardcastle. In her lap sat a little boy. He was about 4 years old with dark, untidy hair and bright, curious eyes. He was stacking wooden blocks into a tower and every time it fell, Lavinia clapped her hands as if it were the finest performance she had ever seen.

Then he turned his face toward the window and the light fell on it. Alister gripped the stone sill to stay on his feet. The boy’s eyes were gray. Not just any gray, but the pale, stormy gray of the Ashford family. The same gray he saw in his own mirror every morning.