At last, when they were as warm as they were going to be, and the old lady was awake and scolding him, and the wind outside had begun at last to drop, he climbed down beside Thomasina in the lamplight. He looked at the pocket board, open on her knee.
“May I?” he said.
She did not answer. She took the pegs from the old lady’s lap, and with fingers that were still stiff and still stained violet, she set them back in the holes where they had been three nights ago, one by one from memory. White had just given up a castle to open the file. Black had not yet answered.
The Duke looked at the position for a long time.
“You posted your move,” he said quietly.
“Three nights ago, to your house in the north. I did not know it was your house. I only knew the direction.”
“I have not had it.”
“No, it will be waiting for you.”
“I do not need it.”
He touched the white castle she had given up lightly with one fingertip.
“You gave me the castle so that your queen could come down the file. In four moves you mate me. I would have seen it by the fifth. I would have sat up all night over it and sworn. And then I would have laughed.”
“I know,” said Thomasina. “You always do. You wrote to me about it once.”
“I wrote to you about everything.”
“Yes.”
“And you answered.”
His voice was not steady.
“Every letter for three winters. You paid for every one of them out of that woman’s wage, did you not?”
She said nothing. That was answer enough.
The Duke reached out and took the little black king from its hole between his big scarred finger and thumb. He held it for a moment. Then he laid it down on its side in the middle of her pocket board. And he said it aloud in front of the clerk and the soldier’s wife, the merchant, the coachman, and the older lady in the purple bonnet.
“I resign. T. Carew has beaten me in the post and at the table and on the heath in the snow. And I called it luck in front of a room full of fools. And I let you be put out into this. I was wrong. I was a coward and I was wrong. And I am more sorry than I know how to say.”
The inside of the coach was perfectly silent.
“I did not ride out here to be forgiven,” said the Duke. “I rode out because you are the only person alive who knows me and I sent you away. I will not do it twice.”
The old lady sniffed loudly.
“Well,” she said. “I should hope not.”
The wagon came an hour before dawn with Gallagher on the box and two grown farm hands with shovels and lanterns and a great heap of straw and sacking in the back. They got the coachman in first and then the old lady and then everyone else. Thomasina went last. The Duke lifted her down from the coach himself and set her in the straw and got in beside her and put his great coat over both of them. Gallagher looked back from the box once and grinned and said nothing at all.