On the recording, Lauren said,
“You’re assuming she’ll open the envelope.”
Declan answered,
“She hates being kept in the dark. Once she thinks Bennett has been hiding something from her, she’ll tear that office apart.”

“And if she finds what you planted?”
My stomach dropped. Declan didn’t answer right away.

Then he said,
“She won’t know it was planted.”
The patio lights blurred at the edges of my vision. I looked at the house beyond the fence, at the open gate Bennett had walked through, and then at Declan standing in front of me like I was still someone he could manage with the right tone of voice.

He had not come to the party because he missed me. He had come because he expected me to do exactly what he wanted. I opened Bennett’s message thread and called him.

He answered on the first ring.
“Are you safe?” he asked.
Not angry. Not triumphant. Just steady.

I swallowed hard.
“How long have you known?”
There was a pause on the line.

“Long enough to make sure you weren’t alone with him,” Bennett said.
“I’m parked two blocks away. Don’t leave with Declan. Don’t go home yet.”

Declan heard him through the speaker. His face changed again.
“You set me up,” he snapped.

Bennett’s voice stayed calm.
“No. You recorded yourself planning to break into my home and frame my wife.”

“I didn’t break in.”
That was when I understood the worst part. Declan hadn’t denied planting something in Bennett’s office.

I looked down at the phone, then replayed the last few seconds of the audio. Beneath Declan’s voice, just before Lauren spoke, there was a small metallic sound. A key turning in a lock.

Not a bar. Not a restaurant. Not some private conversation before a party.

Our front door. And right after that sound, Lauren’s voice said something I hadn’t caught the first time.
“Make sure she sees the photograph before Bennett does.”

The photograph.

For a moment, I could not breathe. My mind kept circling the same question: What photograph could Lauren possibly have planted in Bennett’s office that she needed me to find before him?

Declan saw the answer forming on my face and moved closer.
“You’re hearing one conversation and building a fantasy around it,” he said.
“Bennett wants you scared. That’s what he does when he can’t control the narrative.”

Chapter 3

I almost believed him for half a second.

He had known exactly which words used to work on me. Control. Narrative. Kept in the dark. They were the same phrases he had slipped into every conversation since he arrived, always aimed at the part of me that resented Bennett’s silence.

Then I looked at Declan’s hands.

His right thumb was rubbing hard against the side of his index finger, over and over. He only did that when he lied. He had done it years ago when he told me he had not been texting another woman. He had done it again tonight when he said he had never touched anything in my home.

“You knew about the envelope,” I said.
“You knew I would be angry enough to open it. And Lauren knew enough about our schedules to get inside our house.”

Declan’s mouth flattened.
“You have no proof Lauren entered your house.”

“No,” I said, lifting my phone.
“But Bennett does.”

That landed differently.

His eyes flicked toward the street beyond the fence, toward the dark space where Bennett had said he was waiting. Declan’s confidence cracked for one clean second, then he reached for anger instead.