Then another detail surfaced.
The office door.
Last Thursday, when Bennett and I came home from dinner, I had noticed it was slightly open. I had blamed Bennett. But the door had not just been open.
There had been a smell in the hallway.
Not cologne. Not food. Something clean and sharp.
The same scent Lauren wore at the holiday dinner. I remembered it now because it had clung to the sleeve of my coat after she hugged me goodbye.
I called Bennett again.
He answered before the first ring fully ended.
“Brielle?”
“Lauren sent me a photo,” I said.
“It shows me in your office last Thursday with the blue envelope.”
The silence on the line changed.
Not panic. Recognition.
“Do not delete it,” he said carefully.
“Forward it to me and to yourself. Then step away from Declan.”
“You knew there could be a photo?”
“I knew Lauren had access to something from inside the office,” he said.
“I didn’t know what she planted.”
“Why didn’t you tell me?”
“Because I was trying to confirm whether she was working alone.”
The answer should have made me feel safer. Instead, it made me realize how much had been happening around me without my knowledge.
Then Bennett added,
“Brielle, the blue envelope isn’t where you think it is.”
I looked through the side gate toward the street.
“What do you mean?”
“I moved it yesterday,” he said.
“The one in my desk is a decoy.”
My stomach dropped.
Behind me, Declan had stopped trying to look furious.
He was listening.
And the expression on his face told me the envelope they wanted me to find was not the envelope he expected to be there.
Bennett’s voice was still in my ear, but I stopped looking at the street and looked straight at Declan instead.
He had heard every word. The decoy envelope. The fact that Bennett had moved the real one. The plan he had built so carefully around my anger was suddenly standing on a foundation that was not there.
“What did you expect to be inside it?” I asked.
Chapter 4
Declan gave me a hard stare.
“You’re letting him play you.”
“That is not an answer.”
He glanced toward the driveway again. Tessa’s husband had gone that way looking for Mason, and the people near the grill had stopped pretending this was none of their business. Declan had wanted an audience when he thought I would humiliate Bennett.
Now he had one when he needed to explain himself.
Bennett spoke quietly through the phone.
“Brielle, don’t go back to the house. I called the police after you sent me the recording. They’re on their way.”
Declan’s expression sharpened.
“You called the cops over a conversation?”
“No,” I said.
“Over someone entering my home, planting evidence, and sending me a fabricated photograph.”
He laughed, but there was no confidence behind it.
“Fabricated? You don’t even know that.”
I looked down at the image again. Then I noticed something I had missed because I had been so focused on my own face.
The clock on Bennett’s office wall was visible above the bookshelf.
It read 8:17.
Last Thursday, at 8:17, Bennett and I had been sitting at a restaurant across town. I knew because I had taken a picture of our dessert and sent it to my sister with the time stamped across the top. More importantly, the office clock had stopped working two weeks earlier. Bennett had taken the battery out after it started ticking loudly at night.
The photograph was not just suspicious.