Two days later, he came up the track at noon on foot, leading the cob with Cobb at his knee. He did not knock. He stood in the kitchen doorway with an iron key in his open hand.

“I will show you the door,” said the Duke.

She followed him down the passage. The lock turned with a sound like a stone dropped in a well. The room beyond smelled of cold ash, beeswax, and four winters of being left alone. It was small and plain.

There was a narrow bed stripped to the boards. There was a desk, a chair, a coat on a hook, and a hearth swept long ago. That was all.

Verity stood on the threshold and felt a peculiar shame. She had spent 12 days building a monster behind that door, and the monster was a coat.

“I had a brother,” said the Duke.

She did not move.

“Hugh. He was 26. He owed £4,112 to men who do not forgive debt.”

He stood with his back to her and his eyes on the hearth. Then he turned, and he spoke to her face in the level voice of a man reading a charge he has read to himself a thousand times.

“I did not pay it. I called it a lesson. I wrote the refusal in a letter, and I did not come. I did not answer his second letter for 11 days. I did not read my accounts afterward because accounts were how I had refused him. He came here to hide from his creditors. He took a fever. He died in that bed with my letter on that desk, and my answer was on the road. They say in the Dale that I let him freeze. I let them say it. I did refuse him. That part is true. I have not said it aloud to anyone until today. You may take Culpepper before a magistrate and my name beside his for signing what I wouldn’t read. You may stay the winter. You may go tonight. I want you to stay. You may refuse and nothing is withdrawn. The coal is yours. The lodge is yours. The books are yours. That is all I have.”

The deerhound pressed against his knee. Nobody spoke. Wind moved a shutter somewhere with a small dry knock. Verity looked at the narrow bed and the bare boards and the man who had held the line of his own shoulders for 4 years.

She did not offer him comfort. She had no coin for it. And he would have known.

“You have been signing without reading so that no one could ask you to pay again,” she said.

“Yes.”

“It is an expensive economy, Your Grace.”

“So I have lately found.”

“I shall stay,” said Verity. “I shall finish the books. I will take nothing to a magistrate until I have the whole account. And you will not stop me.”

“I would not.”

“I know,” she said. “That is the difference.”

His eyes, which had been the color of whiskey held to a window, did something she had not seen them do. They let the light in.