One afternoon Genevieve tried pouring his tea in the drawing room. She chattered about a ribbon she had seen in a dressmaker’s window while casually dropping two lumps of sugar into his porcelain cup.

Then she flooded it with cream and slid the cup toward him with a radiant smile. Alistair stared at it. The tea was pale and sweet. For nine years his tea had appeared on his desk precisely at three o’clock, black and scalding, with a razor-thin slice of lemon resting on the saucer. He took a sip of the sugary mixture and felt his stomach turn. “Thank you,” he muttered, struggling to swallow.

Genevieve did not notice his grimace. She failed to notice that the fire had gone out because she had not thought to call a servant. She was oblivious to the draft rattling the windows, a draft Beatrice had always blocked with heavy dark curtains that Genevieve had gleefully ordered removed. The house was cold. It was always uncomfortably cold.

The servants’ silent rebellion was absolute. They did not refuse orders. They merely became incompetent in ways that no one could quite punish. Meals arrived lukewarm. Alistair’s boots were polished but lacked the brilliant shine he had grown accustomed to. When he asked for a particular document from the estate office, it took hours to locate.

One evening, in a fury, Alistair stormed into the kitchens, where he had not set foot since childhood. The room fell silent. The cook, kitchen maids, and footmen all stopped and stared at him. “Where is the winter coal requisition ledger?” he demanded. “The house is freezing, and the merchant says he has not received his quarterly payment.”

The cook, a stout woman who had worshipped Beatrice, wiped her hands on her apron. “Her Grace always dealt with the coal merchant herself, Your Grace. She knew his wife, you see. She always sent a box of biscuits with the order, so he supplied the very best of his stock. We have no such book here. We thought you had taken charge of it.”

Alistair stepped back, his jaw tight. He returned to the library and ransacked the drawers of his mahogany desk. He found only blank paper and dried-up ink. Then he spotted a small silver key at the back of the bottom drawer. It belonged to a locked cabinet in Beatrice’s private sitting room.

He climbed the stairs, passing Genevieve’s room, where she was loudly complaining to her maid about the hardness of the water. He pushed open Beatrice’s door. The room carried a faint scent of dried lavender and old paper. It was bare of personal possessions except for a tall oak cabinet in the corner. Alistair slipped the key into the lock, and it turned with a heavy click.

Inside were rows of carefully labeled, leather-bound ledgers. He drew one out. Estate Maintenance, 1821 to 1823. He opened it. The handwriting was crisp, elegant, and astonishingly precise.

“October 14. The south wall of the tenant farm requires reinforcing. The stone is weak. Do not trust the surveyor’s original estimate. He drinks before noon. Send Jenkins to supervise.”

“November 2. His Grace’s knee aches in damp weather. Ensure the library fire is laid with applewood. It burns hotter and longer. Do not let him notice anyone making a fuss. He hates to feel old.”

Alistair stopped reading. He stared at the words until the ink blurred. “Do not let him notice anyone making a fuss.” Slowly he lowered the book. He had believed Genevieve was fire and Beatrice was ice. But standing within the cold, decaying shell of his own home, holding tangible proof of a decade of quiet, devoted labor, he understood his terrible mistake.

Genevieve was a spark, blazing brightly but giving no true warmth, disappearing as soon as the wind caught it. Beatrice had been the hearth fire. And he had poured water over it, expecting the house to stay warm.

Two hundred miles away, winds swept in from the English Channel, flinging salty spray against the jagged cliffs of Lyme Regis. Beatrice drew her heavy wool shawl closer around her shoulders and leaned into the gale. The cold air stung her cheeks, but for the first time in nearly ten years she could breathe. There was no soot in the air, no stale tobacco smoke, no suffocating perfume, and no burden of managing a man who refused to be managed.