She could not answer.

Then she opened the jewelry box and told him why the silver star had
been hidden for sixteen years.

—

Sandy lifted the silver star from its velvet compartment. “I was
seventeen,” she said. “Henry was eighteen. We thought we were in love,
but we were children pretending we knew how the world worked.”

She told Jack about the pregnancy, the fear, and the arguments between
their families. Henry had wanted to keep the baby. Sandy had wanted that
too, but neither had a stable home, a finished education, or enough
money to raise a child. Her family offered little stability, and the
adults around them offered opinions instead of support.

They met Margaret and Daniel through an adoption counselor. The couple
had waited years to become parents. Sandy remembered Margaret’s gentle
hands and Daniel’s nervous laugh. They promised to tell the child the
truth when she was old enough.

The adoption was closed, though an agency sent occasional updates. Sandy
received letters, birthday cards, and photographs. She kept every one in
a box.

“Why didn’t you tell me?” Jack asked.

“Because I was ashamed. Not of her. Never of her. I was ashamed that I
had been so young and so scared. When we met, I thought you would see me
as someone with a whole other life you hadn’t agreed to.”

“That was my choice to make.”

“I know.”

“You let me believe there was nothing to tell.”

Sandy lowered her eyes. “I know that too.”

Jack stood by the window. He remembered their wedding and their plans
for the future. Whenever he asked about her teenage years, Sandy changed
the subject.

He mistook her silence for healing.

“Does Emma know about me?”

“Not yet. I wanted to tell you first.” She nodded.

“But you were leaving tonight to meet Henry.”

“Emma asked to meet us. I was going to explain after I knew what she
wanted.”

Jack turned. “You were going to tell me after deciding what I was
allowed to know.”

Sandy flinched.

He did not shout. The hurt in his quiet voice was harder to escape.