“Do you want me to read it with you?” he asked.
Sandy nodded.
The first line asked a question Sandy had spent sixteen years fearing:
“Did you ever think about me on my birthday?”
—
Emma’s letter said she loved Margaret and missed Daniel every day. She
was not unhappy with the family who raised her. But after finding
Sandy’s old letters, she wondered whether her birth mother remembered
the day she was born, whether Henry had wanted to keep her, and whether
either of them had ever imagined what she might become.
At the end, Emma wrote: I don’t need you to pretend we were always a
family. I just don’t want to feel like I was a mistake you never speak
about.
Sandy cried. “She wasn’t a mistake. Not for one second.”
“Then tomorrow she needs to hear that from you,” Jack said.
Sandy nodded.
She explained that Emma knew the basic facts, but not how young and
frightened they had been. Henry had wanted to keep the baby, but his
family was unstable. Sandy’s mother was in treatment, and her father had
disappeared. They chose adoption because Margaret and Daniel could offer
a safe home, not because they wanted to erase their child.
Jack asked why the adoption had been closed.
“Henry’s father threatened to take the baby and raise her himself. The
agency advised a closed arrangement until everyone was stable. We
thought it would protect her.”
“Did it?”
“It gave her a good childhood. It also made it harder for her to find
us.”
Jack looked at the silver star on the dresser.
“Bring it tomorrow. If she wants it, let her decide whether to keep it.”
Sandy looked surprised. “You’re really coming?”
“Yes. But no more deciding what I can handle. Not about Emma, not about
Henry, not about us.”
She promised to answer his questions, even when the answers were
difficult.
Then Jack asked why she had believed he would leave.
Sandy stared at the letter for a long moment.
“Because I never believed I deserved a life that stayed.”