Jack looked again at Henry’s photograph and noticed the date: Sandy had
already met Emma twice without telling him.

—

The date on the photograph was two nights earlier.

“I met her once before,” Sandy admitted. “At a coffee shop. Henry came
with her because she wanted him there. Last night was the second time.”

“You told me you were going out with an ex and let me think you were
hiding an affair.”

“I know how it sounds.”

“It sounds like you decided I couldn’t handle the truth.”

Sandy pressed the silver star between her fingers. “I was afraid you
would leave.”

“So you gave me a reason to wonder whether I should.”

He asked whether Henry’s wife knew. Sandy nodded. Her name was Laura,
and she had encouraged Henry to meet Emma. Laura had taken the picture
after Emma asked for one with both biological parents.

“Henry sent it to you?”

“He said you deserved to know before I came home and tried to explain it
badly.”

The picture looked like a family conversation from which Jack had been
excluded.

“Why did you say you’d be home tomorrow morning?”

“Emma wanted to show us the letters she kept. I thought I could explain
everything afterward.”

“You thought I would accept you spending the night with Henry after I
asked you directly?”

Sandy closed her eyes. “I wasn’t thinking clearly.”

Jack sat down. Anger remained, but curiosity had joined it. He wanted to
know the girl in the photograph, the story behind the necklace, and the
birthdays he had never known existed.

“Does Emma want money?”

“No.”

“Does she want to live with you?”

“I don’t know. She has a family. She isn’t trying to replace them.”

“Then what does she want?”

Sandy looked at the picture.

“She wants to know who she came from. She wants to know why we let her
go.”

Jack saw something other than fear in his wife’s face. He saw a mother
waiting sixteen years to answer a question she had never been asked
aloud.