They had been born a year apart and had shared every opinion since.

“How fortunate you are, Miss Fenwick,” said the elder. “So few gentlemen have room for a whole schoolroom.”

“His Grace must be very fond of noise,” said the younger.

“Or very fond of charity,” said the elder, and smiled.

“His Grace is fond of neither,” she said. “He is marrying me because I can add up a column of figures and his steward cannot.”

The punch bowl went quiet. Then the whole near end of the room went quiet. Honoria set down her cup.

“The candles on the left are guttering,” she said. “Somebody should tell Mrs. Hollis before they reach the curtain.”

She walked away. At the far end of the room, the duke stood alone by a pillar with a glass he was not drinking. He had heard. She could tell by the set of his mouth, which was doing something it had perhaps not done in years. She could not, for the life of her, have said why she had done it.

She had only known, standing by the punch bowl, that she would not let two silly women call him kind in that particular voice. But the season was not yet finished with her. A week later, her uncle wrote to the duke. He wrote that it had reached him that His Grace intended to provide for the Fenwick boys. He wrote that the boys’ trust had sadly run dry through no fault of his own, and that he had been obliged to meet the shortfall from his own pocket.

He enclosed four years of accounts. He named a figure he would accept to be repaid. It was nine hundred pounds. The duke laid the accounts on the library table on a Tuesday evening and sent for her. His steward, Mr. Thaddeus Larkin, stood at his elbow.

Larkin was seventy if he was a day. He had disapproved of Honoria from the moment she arrived, on the general grounds that she was new.

“Mr. Culpepper keeps a neat hand,” Larkin observed.

“Neat hands,” said the duke, “are what one generally hires to keep untidy books.”

Honoria took off her gloves. She laid the green ledger open beside her uncle’s accounts. She asked for a pencil, a clean sheet, and an hour without conversation. The duke gave her all three. Larkin gave her a look.

The first error took eleven minutes to find. Her uncle had charged the trust for the boys’ board at Harwick Grange, sixty pounds a year for four years: two hundred and forty pounds.

“They do not board with him,” Honoria said without looking up. “They board with me. I buy their mutton. I darn their stockings. He sends three coals a day.”

She wrote the figure down. The second took twenty minutes more. He had entered the boys’ school fees at ninety pounds a year. The curate at Thistlewood taught Barnaby and Hugh for twelve pounds a year between them. Edmund’s tutor in Ripon took thirty.