Instead, Clara froze.
“A pension, Your Grace?”
“Enough to assure you and your aunt that you will never have to worry about money again.”
“And what should I do in return?”
“Nothing.”
She glanced toward the windows. Taking her silence for hesitation, Alexander began explaining the steps he could take through his lawyer.
That was when she interrupted him.
“You cannot protect my dignity by buying my silence.”
He stared at her.
“I would never dare to attempt such a thing.”
“So why must the answer to every difficulty always be that I stop working to let you provide for me?”
Alexander felt annoyance rising, not because she had insulted him, but because he had never imagined that his generosity could cause pain.
“I’m just trying to help you.”
“I know. That’s what makes the situation so difficult.”
Her voice softened, although her gaze remained tormented.
She explained that a job meant much more than a salary. It allowed her to look after Aunt Agatha without being a burden and gave her a place in the world that she herself had earned. If she accepted a private pension from an unmarried duke, the rumors would not disappear. They would become more credible.
Alexander had not thought of that.
Clara turned toward the window, regaining her composure before continuing.
“The dress I wore at Ashcombe Hall belonged to my mother. She wore it during the last happy summer before my father became ill, and I kept it because so little of her remained.”
She gave a sad smile.
“I spent two days altering it. When it tore, I was afraid of being ridiculed by everyone, but I was also grieving the loss of something I couldn’t afford to replace.”
Alexander listened without saying a word.
“That evening, you were kind even though you had every reason to leave. I will always remember it. But I cannot build my life on the kindness of a gentleman who might one day decide that protecting me has become inconvenient.”
He wanted to assure her that such a day would never come. However, he acknowledged that his conduct offered little evidence of it.
In private, he had sought her company and admired her. In public, he had allowed people to speculate without ever clarifying his own position. He had believed that ignoring gossip was a mark of dignity. For Clara, his silence had become a condemnation.
Their conversation ended without anger, but also without reconciliation.
During the following week, Clara completed her last obligations to Margaret. She refused the duke’s pension and accepted an invitation from a distant cousin in Bath, where she hoped to find work.
Aunt Agatha, although hesitant to leave Yorkshire, understood that her niece needed a place where conversations did not all revolve around a certain party.