Margaret informed Alexander of their departure. He received the news with a calmness that fooled no one. His sister later found him in the library, staring at a book he had not opened.
“You were a fool, Alexander.”
“I am aware of that possibility.”
“Then perhaps you should think carefully about why you were.”
He said nothing.
Margaret sat opposite him and spoke with the frankness permitted only to an elder sister.
“You sat there for three hours when Clara needed you to protect her from embarrassment. Yet when she needed your support in front of society, you chose to remain silent.”
“I thought that drawing attention to the situation would make it worse.”
“For you, perhaps. Your title protects you from the consequences of a rumor. Clara has no protection of that kind.”
Her words remained etched in his mind after Margaret left.
He began examining the charity committee’s correspondence to build a case against Arabella and to understand how a competent woman could have been dismissed without the slightest fault.
The evidence was more disturbing than he had anticipated. Several letters showed that Arabella had pressured donors to reconsider their support. One benefactor had even recorded her warning that, if Clara remained involved, their reputation would suffer from association with the duke’s supposed romantic indiscretion.
Alexander felt a cold anger.
He could have settled the matter with a private threat. Instead, he requested a committee meeting and prepared a written statement, determined to have Clara’s name defended where it had been tarnished.
Before the meeting, a letter arrived from Bath. It was brief and written in Clara’s familiar, careful handwriting. She thanked him for his kindness at Ashcombe Hall and expressed hope that the school would eventually open.
Finally, she added, “You stayed seated once because I asked you not to get up. I hope that one day you will stand up for a cause simply because you know it is right.”
Alexander folded the letter slowly. For several minutes, he remained near his office window, watching the rain accumulate on the glass.
He loved Clara Whitfield, but he was beginning to understand that loving her did not entitle him to her forgiveness. Doing good mattered, even if she never came back.
The next morning, he went to the committee meeting.
For once, the Duke of Hartwell had no intention of remaining seated.
The meeting was held in the village inn’s function room, where the charity committee had gathered to review its plans for the school. Alexander waited until the accounts had been reviewed before getting up.
He spoke without anger, explaining that Clara Whitfield had performed her duties intelligently and with integrity, and that no evidence of inappropriate conduct had ever been found against her.