Alana tried to keep me distracted, but by Sunday night, I could barely follow a conversation. I kept replaying Nathan’s face at the restaurant. His slow applause. That strangely gentle warning. By Monday morning, my confidence had drained away completely.
I called him once. He didn’t answer. I waited ten minutes and called again. Still nothing.
So I left Alana’s apartment, drove home with both hands clenched around the steering wheel, and told myself I was being ridiculous. Nathan’s car was in the driveway when I pulled up. The porch light was on. From the outside, our house looked exactly the same. Inside, it did not feel the same.
Nathan was on the sofa, wearing that same unreadable expression from dinner. Beside him sat the woman in a dark tailored suit, her posture straight, her hands folded in her lap. The manila envelope rested between them.
“Nathan?” My voice came out thin. “What is this?”
The woman turned toward me before he could answer.
“Rachel,” she said, “you need to understand what began the night you chose to embarrass your husband.”
Nathan said nothing. He only slid the envelope across the coffee table until it stopped near my knees. I stared at it. Then I saw the name printed across the front, and my hands started shaking before I could bring myself to touch it.
The name on the envelope was Mason Hale. For a second, I honestly thought I was reading it wrong. Mason had been out of my life for nearly eight years. I hadn’t said his name in our house. I hadn’t searched for him, called him, or asked anyone about him. The only reason Nathan even knew he existed was because I had once mentioned an old relationship in the most casual, dismissive way possible.
Yet there it was, printed in black block letters across the envelope.
MASON HALE—CONFIDENTIAL.
I looked from the envelope to Nathan.
“Why is his name in my living room?”
The woman beside him stood, keeping a careful distance from both of us.
“My name is Erin Caldwell. I’m an attorney.”
My stomach dropped. Nathan finally spoke.
“Erin represents me.”
“You hired a lawyer?” I asked.
His face didn’t harden. That somehow hurt worse.
“I met with her Friday morning.”
Chapter 3
Friday. The morning after I left for Alana’s apartment. I stared at him, waiting for the anger to arrive. I wanted him to accuse me of something so I could fight back. I wanted a slammed door, a raised voice, anything familiar.
Instead, he sat there with his hands loosely folded, looking exhausted.
“You disappeared for three days because you were planning to divorce me?” I asked.
“I didn’t disappear,” he said quietly. “I stayed here. I answered work calls. I met with an attorney. And I tried to figure out whether I had married someone who only pretended to respect me.”
His words landed harder than shouting would have. I reached for the envelope, but Erin lifted one hand.