“Before you open it, I need you to understand that Nathan did not go looking for Mr. Hale.”
My fingers stopped in the air.
“What does that mean?”
“It means Mr. Hale contacted this office first.”
The room seemed to tilt. Nathan’s eyes stayed on mine.
“He sent something addressed to me at work last week. I didn’t open it at first. I thought it was junk mail.”
“And then?” I asked.
“Then Thursday happened.”
I understood immediately. My joke. My friends laughing. Nathan’s face when I compared him to the man I had spent years trying to forget.
The ugly thing was, I had never told Nathan why Mason and I ended. I had always made it sound simple: wrong timing, immature relationship, nothing worth revisiting. That wasn’t the truth.
I took the envelope from the table before Erin could stop me. My hands were steady now, which surprised me. Fear had a way of making me sharper when there was no room left for pride. Inside was a short letter on thick white paper, a copy of what looked like a text conversation, and one glossy photograph.
The photograph made my chest tighten. It was Alana’s apartment building. Not the front entrance. The side entrance, near the alley where residents carried groceries in from the parking garage. The photo had been taken Sunday afternoon.
I knew that because I was standing in it. My face was turned away from the camera. I was wearing Alana’s oversized gray hoodie, holding a paper cup of coffee, looking down at my phone. I had no idea anyone had been watching.
“Nathan,” I said, my voice suddenly low, “where did you get this?”
“He included it.”
“No.” I held the photo up. “I mean why would Mason have this?”
Nathan’s jaw tightened for the first time.
“That is what I asked him.”
I looked at the text messages next. They were supposedly between me and Mason. My name appeared at the top of the page. His number appeared beneath it. The messages claimed I had contacted him late Thursday night after Nathan left the restaurant.
According to the printout, I had written:
I finally said what I should have said years ago. You were right about him.
My skin went cold.
“I never sent this.”
Erin’s expression remained professional, but not cold.
“Mr. Hale provided the messages as part of a statement he asked us to deliver to Nathan. He claims you resumed contact several months ago.”
“That is a lie.”
Nathan looked away. It was a small movement, but I saw it.
“You believe him,” I said.
“I don’t know what to believe,” he answered. “I know you humiliated me in front of our friends. I know you left for the weekend without caring whether I was okay. And then a man you once dated sends me pictures of you, messages with your name on them, and a letter saying you’ve been talking about leaving me.”
“I did not say that to him.”
“But have you said it to anyone else?”
The question was fair. That made it unbearable. I had complained about Nathan to Alana. To Jessica. To people at brunch who barely knew him. I had made him the punch line because it made me feel powerful to be the one with the sharpest story.