“I came in because I heard you upstairs and found a stranger locked in our closet.”
Graham rose slowly, brushing carpet fibers from his pants.
“I should leave.”
“No,” I said.
My voice surprised even me. It wasn’t loud, but it stopped him cold.
“You don’t walk out of my house until you tell me who you are.”
He swallowed. Erin’s gaze cut toward him so sharply that he seemed to shrink back. Before he could answer, she said:
“His name is Graham. He knows someone I work with.”
Graham turned his head toward her.
“That’s not what you said downstairs.”
The room went silent again. Erin’s expression changed in an instant.
“Don’t say another word.”
That was when I noticed what Graham had been holding the whole time. A silver wristwatch. My wristwatch.
The watch had a narrow scratch across the clasp, from the day it caught on a filing cabinet at work. I had searched for it for weeks after it disappeared from my dresser almost four months ago. I checked under the bed, inside laundry baskets, in the garage, even in the glove compartment of my car. Erin had helped me look.
I held out my hand.
“Where did you get that?”
Graham’s fingers closed tighter around it. Instead of answering me, he looked at Erin. She wouldn’t look at either of us.
“He found it in the closet,” she said.
I let out one short breath.
“The closet you were physically blocking me from opening?”
“It must have fallen behind something,” she said, but the words came out thin and rushed.
I stepped toward the closet. Erin grabbed my forearm. Her nails dug through my shirt sleeve, and the anger she had been using as a shield vanished completely.
“Darren, don’t.”
That one word told me more than every excuse she had offered since I walked in. I pulled my arm free.
“Move.”
“Please.”
I opened the closet door anyway. The hanging clothes swayed from the motion. Near the back wall, partly hidden behind Erin’s winter coats, was a black leather bag I had never seen before. It was too clean to belong in a crowded closet, and the zipper had been left partly open.
Graham took one step forward.
“Don’t touch that,” Erin said.
Neither of them was talking to me. I crouched and pulled the bag into the light. Inside was my watch case—the same wooden case that had vanished from the top of my dresser months ago. Beside it sat a copy of our house key. Not the spare we kept in the kitchen drawer, but a separate key, cut and worn around the edges as if someone had used it often.
My stomach dropped. Then I saw the photographs. They were stacked together and held with a plain rubber band. My hands felt strangely steady as I slid the band off and lifted the top picture.
Graham stood in my driveway. The photo had been taken from across the street, angled toward our garage. His face was clear enough that there was no doubt. He wasn’t walking past our home. He was watching it.