The next photograph showed him at our back door. His hand was on the handle. Both pictures looked recent, though neither had a printed date.

I turned toward Erin.

“How long has he had a key to our house?”

She pressed her lips together.

Chapter 2

Graham’s voice came out low.

“It wasn’t supposed to happen like this.”

“What wasn’t?”

He didn’t answer. I looked through the remaining pictures, my pulse beating harder with every page. There were shots of our driveway, the side gate, even the back windows. Some had been taken weeks earlier. The bag wasn’t full, but it held enough to make one fact impossible to deny.

This wasn’t a repair visit. This wasn’t a stranger who happened to be trapped in a closet. Then I reached the last photograph. It was older than the others, the corners faded and slightly curled. A crowded charity reception filled the frame—people in formal clothes, tables with white linens, blurred faces beneath ballroom lights.

Graham stood near the edge of the picture beside a younger version of me. I was wearing the charcoal suit I had bought for a company fundraiser ten years ago. I remembered the suit. I remembered the ballroom. I remembered spending the evening shaking hands with coworkers and donors until my face hurt.

But I did not remember Graham Pierce. Not even a little. I flipped the picture over. A date had been written on the back in Erin’s handwriting. Under it was a single sentence. My throat tightened as I started to read it aloud.

Graham stepped closer, his face drained of color.

“Darren,” he whispered, “don’t read that yet.”

I looked up. His eyes were fixed on the photograph in my hand.

“Look behind you,” he said. “At the person standing in the background.”

I turned the picture over again—and finally saw the face I had somehow missed. The face in the background belonged to Erin. She was younger, her hair darker and cut just above her shoulders, but there was no mistaking her once I saw it. She stood near a service door at the far end of the ballroom, half-shadowed behind a cluster of guests.

Her eyes were aimed directly at me. Not at the camera. At me. My hand went numb around the photograph.

“You were there.”

Erin didn’t deny it. She slowly lowered herself onto the edge of the bed, as if her knees had stopped cooperating. Graham stayed near the closet, silent now, his attention fixed on her instead of me.

“That event was ten years ago,” I said. “We met eight years ago.”

“I know when we met, Darren.”

“Then why are you in this picture?”

The question seemed to fill every corner of the room. Downstairs, the refrigerator motor clicked on. A car passed outside. Ordinary sounds kept happening while my life tilted into something I no longer recognized. Erin reached toward the photograph, but I pulled it back.