He had wondered who taught her to do that. He had wondered whether anyone ever asked what she wanted.

When he saw her at the general store, kneeling beside a broken basket, he had been grateful for an excuse to speak to her. He had found that she was thoughtful, intelligent, and quietly amusing. Every conversation left him wanting another. By the time he asked her to dance, he knew it was not a passing interest.

He admired her. He wanted to know her better. And he hoped she might someday feel comfortable enough to show him the joyful side of herself that appeared only in brief, unguarded moments.

That evening, when Caleb entered the barn, he looked for the blue dress Lily had mentioned. He did not see it. He greeted Mrs. Hadley, spoke to several neighbors, and helped an older gentleman find a chair. Then he searched again.

May stood near the supper table in her pink dress. Caleb approached politely.

“Good evening, Miss Dawson.”

May smiled brightly.

“Good evening, Mr. Ward.”

“Have you seen your sister?”

The smile faltered.

“Lily?”

“Yes.”

May looked toward the far doors.

“I believe she went outside.”

“Thank you.”

Caleb noticed something strange in her expression. But he did not press her. He moved toward the doors and stepped into the cool evening air.

The lanterns cast long shadows across the yard. Horses stood quietly beside the fence, and the sky above the western fields had turned a deep blue.

Caleb walked toward the Dawson wagon. Lily was not there. He looked beside the stable. Still nothing. Then he noticed something lying in the dust. A narrow strip of blue ribbon.

He recognized it immediately. He had seen the same ribbon tucked into Lily’s sewing basket weeks earlier. She had mentioned that it was meant for her hair. Caleb bent and picked it up. It was dusty and slightly stretched. He turned it carefully between his fingers.

Then he heard a faint sound from behind the barn. It might have been the wind. It might have been someone crying. He followed it.

When he turned the corner, he found Lily sitting alone beside the fence. Her head was bent. Her beautiful fair hair had fallen loose and tangled around her shoulders. Her blue dress was still carefully arranged, but its skirt had gathered dust near the hem. She looked so small and lonely beneath the wide evening sky that Caleb felt something tighten painfully inside his chest.

He stopped several steps away. He did not want to frighten her.

“Lily?”

She looked up. For a moment, Caleb could see nothing but the hurt in her eyes. Then she hurriedly wiped her cheeks.

“Caleb.”

He remained where he was.

“I hope I am not disturbing you.”

Lily attempted to smile.

“No. Of course not.”

He looked at the ribbon in his hand.

“I found this beside the stable.”

Her eyes fell to it.

“Oh.”

“Is it yours?”

“Yes.”

He stepped closer, but stopped before reaching her.

“May I return it?”

She nodded. Caleb held it out. Lily took the ribbon carefully, avoiding his eyes.

“Thank you.”

“You are welcome.”

He looked at the bench beside her.

“Would you prefer to be alone, or might I sit with you?”

Lily stared at him. Nobody had asked her that question all evening. She was used to being told where to go and what to do. People sent her to the kitchen, the stable, the washing line, or the pantry. But Caleb did not tell her to stand, smile, hurry, or explain. He simply asked what she wanted. The gentleness nearly brought fresh tears to her eyes.

“You may sit,”

she whispered.

Caleb sat at the far end of the bench, leaving a comfortable space between them. For a while, neither spoke. The music drifted through the barn wall. Somewhere in the distance, an owl called. Lily twisted the ribbon between her fingers.

At last, Caleb said,

“It is a fine evening.”

She gave a weak laugh.

“It was supposed to be.”

He turned slightly toward her.

“I am sorry it has not been.”

Lily stared at the ribbon.

“My hair looks dreadful.”

Caleb glanced at her carefully.

“It looks as though someone has had a difficult time with it.”

She laughed once, but the sound broke. Then the tears came again.

“I am sorry.”

“There is nothing to apologize for.”

She wiped her cheeks.

“I must look terribly foolish.”

“No.”

“I spent weeks preparing.”

“I know.”

“I wanted everything to be lovely.”

Caleb remained silent, giving her time. Lily looked down at her hands.

“My sister pulled the ribbon from my hair. She tangled the braid, and I cannot seem to make it right.”

Caleb’s expression grew serious.

“Did she hurt you?”

“Only for a moment.”