“He did.”
May laughed.
“How surprising.”
Lily kept her voice steady.
“Why surprising?”
“Oh, nothing. I only thought he might ask one of the more accomplished girls.”
“May,”
Marian said, though without much force.
May lifted her shoulders.
“Well, she says herself that she cannot dance.”
Lily looked down.
“I told him that.”
“And he still asked?”
“Yes.”
May tapped her fingers against the table.
“Then I suppose he is kinder than most.”
Lily felt the old doubt creeping back. Marian set down her cup.
“Do not make too much of it, Lily. A gentleman may ask a young woman to dance without intending anything serious.”
“I know.”
“Good. I should not like you to embarrass yourself.”
Lily swallowed.
“I have no intention of embarrassing anyone.”
May turned toward the window.
“I wonder whether he has asked anyone else.”
The conversation moved on. But Lily ate very little supper. Later, she carried the dishes to the kitchen while May practiced a few dance steps near the parlor mirror. Marian inspected the pantry and listed the food Lily would need to prepare the following morning.
Nobody mentioned the invitation again. When the house finally grew quiet, Lily went to her room and took out the blue dress. She hung it beside the window. The moonlight touched the fabric. It looked almost silver.
She thought of Caleb’s smile. Then perhaps we can be imperfect together. The words had been lighthearted, but their kindness stayed with her. He had not asked whether she knew the latest dances. He had not asked whether she possessed a fashionable dress. He had simply asked whether she would dance with him.
Lily touched the ribbon lying on her pillow. She wanted to believe that a gentleman could choose her because he enjoyed her company, not because he felt sorry for her.
The next morning, she rose early and worked harder than usual. She scrubbed the kitchen floor, prepared bread, repaired a torn tablecloth, and finished the laundry before noon. By afternoon, she was exhausted.
Marian noticed the completed work.
“You have been unusually industrious.”
Lily smiled.
“I wanted to be sure there would be nothing left unfinished when the ball comes.”
Marian folded her arms.
“There will always be work on a farm.”
“I know.”
“Then do not imagine one dance changes your responsibilities.”
Lily looked at her stepmother. For years, she would have lowered her eyes and apologized. This time, something inside her resisted.
“I do not imagine that, Mother.”
Marian seemed surprised. Lily continued quietly.
“But I should like one evening when being responsible does not mean I must be forgotten.”
The kitchen fell silent. Marian looked at her for a long moment. Then she turned away.
“See that the bread does not burn.”
Lily returned to the stove, her hands trembling slightly. She had not shouted. She had not been disrespectful. She had only spoken a truth that had lived inside her for years. And though the conversation had brought no promise of change, Lily felt that something important had begun.
Two days before the ball, May entered Lily’s bedroom while she was finishing the last stitches. The blue dress lay across the bed, the ribbon beside it.
May stopped. For several moments, she said nothing. Then she reached toward the ribbon.
“That is very pretty.”
Lily looked up.
“Thank you.”
“Where did you get it?”
“Mrs. Bell let me purchase it.”
May lifted the ribbon between her fingers.
“It would look lovely with my pink dress.”
Lily’s heart tightened.
“Perhaps. But I bought it for mine.”
May glanced at her.
“You have never refused me a ribbon before.”
“I know.”
“Then why are you refusing now?”
Lily placed her needle carefully on the table.
“Because I have been saving it for the ball.”
May’s expression hardened.
“You are behaving as though this ball were the most important event of your life.”
Lily looked at her sister.
“Perhaps it is important to me.”
May laid the ribbon down. There was a strange hurt in her eyes, almost hidden beneath resentment. Then she spoke softly.
“You have never minded being the plain one before. Why must you start now?”
Lily felt the words settle like cold stones in her chest. She wanted to explain that she had never chosen to stand aside. She wanted to tell May that being quiet was not the same as being content. But May had already turned toward the door.
And Lily was left wondering whether the first happiness she had dared to claim would survive the jealousy growing inside her own home.
Chapter 4: THE COURAGE TO WANT SOMETHING
On the morning before the ball, Willow Creek looked as though every building had been washed clean by sunlight. The sky was a clear blue, and the prairie wind carried the smell of new grass. Women arrived at the Hadley barn with baskets of food, bundles of flowers, and cloth for decorating the tables. Men carried benches, hung lanterns, and cleared a wide space for dancing. Children ran between the wagons until someone called them back.