“I’m sorry.”

There were many kinds of apology. Some were bridges. Some were bandages. Some were only words spoken because silence had become unbearable.

Hannah did not yet know which kind his would become. She nodded. Then went inside.

In her room, she sat on the edge of the bed with the parcel in her lap. Her hands trembled as she untied the string. Inside was a pair of leather gloves. Not fancy gloves. Work gloves.

Soft, well-made ones lined with wool. Hannah stared. A small folded note rested between them. She opened it.

Hannah,

You complained last month that the old pair lets wind through every finger. You were right.

William

That was all. Hannah laughed. Then she cried.

Not loudly. She held the gloves against her chest and cried for everything she had tried not to feel. For the chair that had not been there. For the father who had not stood.

For a stepmother who believed pain was performance. For a man who remembered a complaint Hannah herself had forgotten making. Someone knocked. Hannah wiped her eyes quickly.

“Who is it?”

“Samuel.”

“Come in.”

He entered carrying a plate piled so high with food that gravy threatened to spill over one side.

“What is that?”

“Christmas dinner.”

“I have dinner.”

He glanced at the mostly untouched plate she had brought upstairs.

“Not enough.”

He placed his plate on her lap.

“Samuel…”

“I told them I was full.”

“You’re never full.”

“I know.”

She smiled. He looked at the gloves.

“From Cole?”

“Yes.”

“He likes you.”

Hannah nearly dropped the plate.

“He is kind to many people.”

Samuel rolled his eyes.

“Not like that.”

“You are thirteen.”

“That doesn’t mean I’m blind.”

“Out.”

He grinned. At the door, he stopped.

“Hannah?”

“Yes?”

“I would’ve sat outside.”

Her throat tightened.

“I know.”

He left before she could embarrass him by crying again. Hannah looked down at the overloaded plate. Then at the new gloves. Christmas had hurt her.

It had also shown her something she had not understood before. There were people in her life who would make room. And there were people who expected her to keep shrinking. For the first time, Hannah wondered how long she intended to stay small.

CHAPTER 4: AFTER CHRISTMAS

The valley heard about the porch before New Year’s Day. Hannah was not surprised. News traveled faster than horses. At the general store, Mrs. Beasley squeezed Hannah’s hand and said,

“Your cooking deserved a chair if nothing else.”

At church, two women looked at Hannah and then immediately stopped whispering. At the blacksmith shop, Amos apparently told three men that William Cole had “made half the Mercer family swallow their dinner sideways.” Hannah wished everyone would forget it. William seemed to understand. He did not visit for almost two weeks.

Then one afternoon, while Hannah was carrying grain to the chickens, she heard a wagon. William drove into the yard with fence wire, two sacks of salt, and a broken shovel belonging to Robert. Hannah stood beside the coop. He climbed down.

“Afternoon.”

“Afternoon.”

Neither mentioned Christmas. William unloaded the salt. Hannah fed the chickens. Finally, he looked at her hands.

“You’re wearing them.”

She looked down at the gloves.

“Yes.”

“They fit?”

“Perfectly.”

“Good.”

Silence again. Hannah smiled.

“You’ve become shy.”

William lifted a brow.

“I sat on a freezing porch without invitation.”

“That’s not evidence against shyness.”

“It should be.”

She walked closer.

“Thank you.”

He grew serious.

“You already did.”

“No.”

Hannah shook her head.

“I thanked you for the gloves.”

He waited. She looked toward the house. Margaret was somewhere inside. Robert was in the southern pasture. The children were at school.

“I mean Christmas.”

William leaned against the wagon.

“You don’t owe me thanks for sitting down.”

“It mattered.”

“I know.”

The simple answer caught her. Hannah studied him.

“How?”

“How what?”

“How did you know it mattered?”

William looked across the yard. For a moment she thought he might avoid the question. Instead he said,

“Because I know what it looks like when someone is pretending something doesn’t hurt.”

Hannah waited. He did not explain more. She did not ask. Some wounds deserved privacy until a person chose to open them. William pushed away from the wagon.

“Your father asked me to look at the north fence.”

“I thought you came to inspect my gloves.”

“That too.”

She laughed. His expression softened.

For the next month, nothing dramatic happened. That was how their closeness began. Not with declarations. With ordinary days. William came to help repair a section of fencing after a storm.

Hannah brought coffee. He stopped by with a jar of honey from a neighbor because Hannah had once mentioned the children liked it. She mended a tear in his coat after he caught it on barbed wire. He protested.

She ignored him. He sharpened her kitchen knives. She complained they were now so sharp she feared losing a finger. He said,

“Try not to.”

By February, William no longer waited to be invited into the kitchen. Margaret disliked this. Hannah knew because Margaret became extremely polite whenever William appeared. Extreme politeness was her coldest form of anger.

One snowy afternoon, William sat at the kitchen table drinking coffee while Hannah rolled biscuit dough. Margaret entered.

“Mr. Cole.”

“Mrs. Mercer.”

“I didn’t know we had company.”

“I’m not company,”

William said. Hannah looked down quickly to hide her smile. Margaret noticed.

“Of course.”

She opened a cupboard. William took another sip of coffee. Margaret removed a bowl.

Then another. Then replaced both. Finally, she faced him.

“You’ve been here often.”

William’s voice remained calm.

“Have I?”

“You know you have.”

“Yes.”

Hannah stopped rolling dough. Margaret looked directly at him.

“What are your intentions?”

“Margaret,”

Hannah said. William did not look embarrassed. He did not look amused either. He placed the cup down.

“My intentions are respectful.”

“That is not an answer.”

“It’s the answer Hannah is entitled to hear before anyone else.”

Hannah’s heart stumbled. Margaret stared. William looked at Hannah. Neither spoke for several seconds. Then he stood.