“I know.”

William followed her gaze. Then he said,

“She has.”

Margaret’s eyes shifted back.

“Has what?”

“Forgiven more than I would have.”

Margaret swallowed.

“She always did.”

William’s tone was gentle but firm.

“That doesn’t mean she should always have to.”

Margaret nodded.

“I know.”

From across the field, Hannah saw them talking. She did not hear the words. She did not need to. Sometimes healing happened without witnesses.

CHAPTER 8: A QUESTION AT THE CREEK

Rain came in September. The whole valley celebrated. Children stood outside with mouths open.

Men who had spent months complaining about mud gladly walked through it. Hannah watched water run from the roof and laughed. William found her standing beneath the porch.

“You’ll catch cold.”

“That is something old women say.”

“My mother said it.”

“Then she was probably wiser than you.”

“Almost certainly.”

He stepped beside her. They watched rain darken the yard. William had been courting Hannah for seven months.

Everyone expected him to propose. Hannah knew because everyone tried not to ask. Samuel was especially bad at not asking.

“So when are you leaving?” he had said at breakfast.

“Leaving?”

“When you marry Cole.”

Hannah had nearly choked on coffee. Now William stood beside her beneath the porch roof. Hannah thought of Christmas. The same boards.

The same doorway. Different weather. Different woman. William touched her hand.

“Walk with me.”

“In the rain?”

“You’re already wet.”

“I’m barely wet.”

“You were standing beyond the roofline when I arrived.”

“That proves nothing.”

William smiled. They walked toward the creek. Rain softened into a mist. The cottonwood leaves had begun turning yellow.

At the water, William stopped. Hannah looked at him. Something about his face made her heart race.

“No speech?” she asked.

“I tried writing one.”

“Oh?”

“Burned it.”

“Why?”

“It sounded like someone else.”

Hannah smiled. William took both her hands.

“Hannah, I love you.”

The smile disappeared. There it was. Simple. Direct. William.

“I love the way you care for people. I love that you can be gentle without being weak. I love that you laugh when you’re tired and argue when you know you’re right.”

“Only when I know?”

“Most of the time.”

She laughed through tears. William continued.

“I don’t want you because you need saving.”

Hannah became still. He understood. Of course he did.

“I want you because when I’m with you, home feels less like land and more like a place I want to return to.”

A tear slid down Hannah’s cheek. William reached into his coat. The ring was simple. Silver, with a small polished stone.

“My mother’s.”

Hannah stared.

“I’ve kept it fourteen years.”

“William.”

“I would like you to wear it.”

He took a breath.

“Will you marry me?”

Hannah looked at the man who had first chosen the cold step beside her. But she knew now that one Christmas moment was not why she loved him. She loved him because afterward he had continued choosing her. In ordinary weather. In drought.

In silence. In work. In laughter. In all the days when no one was watching.

“Yes.”

William closed his eyes. Hannah laughed.

“Were you uncertain?”

“Yes.”

“After seven months?”

“Especially after seven months. You know all my faults now.”

“Not all.”

He groaned. She held out her hand. William slid the ring onto her finger. It fit.

“Did you measure?”

He looked proud.

“I asked Clara.”

Hannah gasped.

“That traitor.”

“She demanded two peppermint sticks.”

“You bribed my sister?”

“Business arrangement.”

Hannah laughed so hard she had to lean against him. William wrapped his arms around her. Rain whispered in the cottonwoods. The creek moved beside them.

There were no witnesses. No applause. No music. It was perfect.

CHAPTER 9: MAKING ROOM

The wedding was planned for November. Not because Hannah wanted a grand event. She wanted something small. Church. Family.

Neighbors. Food. Margaret insisted on sewing the wedding dress. Hannah resisted.

“You have enough work.”

“So do you.”

“I can sew my own.”

“I know.”

“Then why…”

Margaret’s hands tightened around the fabric.

“Because I would like to.”

Hannah stopped. Margaret looked down.

“I have not given you many things that were only for you.”

The room became quiet. Hannah touched the cream fabric. It was not expensive. But it was beautiful.

“You don’t owe me a dress.”

“I know.”

Those three words. The same ones William had used about the gloves. Hannah smiled faintly.

“All right.”

Margaret worked for six weeks. She stitched late at night. Adjusted the sleeves three times. Added tiny pearl buttons that had belonged to her own mother.

When Hannah tried the finished dress, Margaret stood behind her before the mirror. Neither spoke for a long moment. Finally Margaret said,

“Your mother would have wanted to do this.”

Hannah’s breath caught.

“Yes.”

“I used to resent her.”

Hannah turned. Margaret looked ashamed.

“A dead woman.”

“You never knew her.”

“That made it easier. I could imagine she had been perfect.”

Hannah smiled sadly.

“She wasn’t.”

“No?”

“She burned bread. Often.”

Margaret blinked. Hannah continued.

“She hated sewing sleeves. She sang terribly. She once chased a rooster around the yard with a broom and fell into a water trough.”

Margaret laughed. A real laugh. Hannah laughed too. Then Margaret began crying. It shocked them both.

“I am sorry,” she whispered.

Hannah’s smile faded. Margaret took her hands.

“I’m sorry I treated your love for her as though it threatened my place here.”

Hannah felt tears rise. Margaret continued.

“And I’m sorry I made you feel like there was less room for you because I wanted more room for myself.”

The Christmas table appeared in Hannah’s mind. The porch. The plate. The cold. She squeezed Margaret’s hands.

“I wanted you to love me.”

Margaret cried harder. Hannah had never admitted that. Not even to herself.

“I think,”

Margaret said,

“I was afraid to.”

“Why?”

“Because you were hers.”

Hannah shook her head.

“I was twelve.”

“I know.”

“You could have been mine too.”

Margaret covered her mouth. For one terrible, tender moment, both women stood surrounded by everything that could not be changed. Then Margaret stepped forward. Hannah let her. They embraced.