For six days, I imagined every possible calamity. Illness. A separation. Some new ruin Tristan had brought upon the household. I did not imagine the truth. I do not think anyone could have.

On Christmas Eve, I arrived at my parents’ house at a quarter to five. Carriages stood along both sides of the road. Aunts, uncles, cousins—the whole Callahan connection had assembled.

Before entering, I gave the waiting postboy a note for Marianne. I wrote that I loved her. It was the first time I had said it, and not remotely the occasion I had intended. Her answer, when it eventually reached me, contained no hesitation.

Then I went round to the coach house.

Jane sat on an overturned bucket beside an old traveling chest, clutching a folder against her breast as though it were a shield. She had been crying.

“Tristan and Beatrice are inside,” she said before I could speak. “They never went to Bath. Mother lied.”

For a moment, the flagstones seemed to give way beneath me.

“That is not what I need to show you.”

She handed me the folder.

In the spring, Mother had asked Jane to put her correspondence in order. Old letters were to be sorted, and copies of new dispatches entered in a household letterbook. Mother disliked clerks knowing her affairs, and Jane’s dependence made her seem a safer amanuensis than a servant.

In July, while sorting a packet, Jane had found Beatrice’s name on a letter written long before the broken engagement. She had read it. Then she had begun preserving what followed.

The folder contained incoming letters and careful copies of Mother’s replies. Jane had marked the dates on every sheet. The originals remained in Mother’s writing box; the copies preserved even her corrections and the words she underlined. Some of the incoming letters were there in Beatrice’s own hand.

The first was dated August of the previous year. Eight months before I opened my bedchamber door. Eight months.

“I believe I am falling in love with Tristan,” Beatrice had written, “and I do not know what I ought to do.”

Mother’s answer was beneath it.

“Do not dare make a scandal that will destroy this family. Owen need know nothing. Allow the foolishness to run its course.”

I had to sit on the traveling chest. Jane turned the pages because my hands would not obey me.

October.

“Tristan is exceedingly amusing,” Beatrice wrote, “but Owen is the man with a future.”

“Precisely,” Mother replied. “Therefore be sensible. Let the marriage take place. Once you are his wife, Owen will not leave you. Owen never leaves.”

I read that last sentence four times.

Owen never leaves.

My mother had built an entire arrangement upon my loyalty, as though it were a load-bearing wall upon which she could hang whatever weight she pleased.

Then came the letters written after I discovered them.

“If Owen ceases contributing to the house, we shall lose it. Keep Tristan quiet and leave Owen to me.”