The fire burned down to a red seam. On the desk, under a glass paperweight, lay a column of newsprint cut from The Times with a penknife. It had been folded and unfolded so many times that the crease had gone soft as linen. Beneath the familiar lines was the one he had not read aloud.

“Papa is not as bad as people say.”

It had been underlined in pencil twice. She had thought that first wet Tuesday that he stopped one line short out of contempt. It had not been contempt. He had stopped because it was the one line in the advertisement he could not say aloud in front of strangers. Not because it was false, because he did not know whether it was true.

The whole of that morning turned over in her hands like a coin and showed its other face.

“I keep it there,” said the duke from the doorway, “because I cannot think where else to put it.”

He was in his shirtsleeves with a candle. Captain stood at his knee and thumped his tail twice against the doorframe.

“You did not read the last line,” said Rowena. “That first day. May I ask why?”

He set the candle down beside the cutting. Then he looked out of the black window towards the place on the lawn where the cedar stood.

“You asked me when we made our terms never to cut that tree.”

“I did.”

“You took my silence for temper.”

“I did,” said Rowena. “I wrote it down.”

He almost smiled. Then he did not.

“My father had those limbs sawn off the summer I was seven because I had climbed to the top and been seen from the drawing room by his guests. He did not shout, and he did not strike me, and he did not say one word to me about it afterwards. He had the gardeners take them off in front of me, one limb an hour, all afternoon, and he made me stand on the gravel and watch until it was done. I did not climb again. I did not laugh where he could hear it. I did not go near anything I loved where he could see, because whatever he saw me love, he took away.”

“I learned it so thoroughly that I cannot unlearn it. When I stand at the foot of those nursery stairs, I hear the saw. Five governesses. Each of them, I discovered, had locked my daughter in the linen press for climbing. That was my father’s method, exactly. I dismissed each one on the day I learned it, and the county called it temper, and I let them.”

“The settlement is yours, whatever you decide. If you wish to live in Bath or London or anywhere that is not this house, the money follows you and nothing is withdrawn. I should like to come up to the nursery. I will not come unless you say I may. You may say no.”